topleft
topright

Main Menu

Home
Assessment Guidelines
Organizational Politics
Public Politics
Classroom Politics
Psychological Types
Discussion - 10/08 Results E-mail
Article Index
Discussion - 10/08 Results
Participants
Political Orientation
Analytical Strategy
16 Types
Jungian Types
Temperament
Mental Functions
TF x JP
SN x JP
EI x JP
Comments on Type Groups
Type and Demographics
Clusters
Summary Discussion
A Proposed Model
Thanks
 

 

Summary Discussion

 

 

Objectives

 

The primary purpose of the final (October 08) Type and Politics Poll was to examine in more detail the relationship between psychological type preferences and political orientations.  Prior research in both the psychological type field as well as research employing the Five-Factor Model (FFM) of personality has suggested that the S-N preferences clearly seem to be related to political orientations in terms of "liberal" and "conservative" orientations.  Most of these studies, however, have used only a single item to measure these orientations.

 

Our purpose in the final poll was to extend this research in two ways.  First, we created measures based on the assumption that there are at least two related dimensions of liberal and conservative orientations--one concerning social issues and the other concerning economic issues.  Second, we created measures to reflect participants' political self-perceptions of themselves as liberal or conservative on social and economic issues as well as measures that reported political attitudes toward economic and social issues. Our approach to liberal-conservative political orientation thus was multidimensional.  Given the various theoretical frameworks that suggest people seek cognitive consistency (or avoid cognitive dissonance) in terms of ego identity, however, we should expect these different orientations to be related (as was shown in the correlations of the five measures).

 

During our analyses we also kept in mind the ongoing debate surrounding whole types. Thus, we analyzed our data in terms of whole types (and subtypes) as well as at the level of the individual preferences.

 

 

Results

 

 

Sample

 

Before looking at the results of the analyses, it is important to keep in mind the nature of the sample upon which the analyses are based. In particular, most (66%) of the participants reported being APTi members. Thus, it should not be surprising that a large proportion of the sample members reported preferences for Intuition (77%) and were female (59%). ENFPs constituted the modal type (17%) followed by INTJs (11%) and INFPs (11%). Further, as is not unusual, the SPs constituted only a small proportion (14%) of the sample. These results suggest the subtype analyses likely are more reliable than the  whole-type analyses given that the number of observations for each subtype are larger than for the whole-type or Jungian-type analyses.

 

The tendency of the participants to score more liberal on each of the political orientation measures in the type-only analyses (i.e., those without demographics included) also should be considered.  As was shown in each of the type-only analyses, participants, on average, provided slightly liberal to more strongly liberal responses on each of the political orientation measures.  This skew of the responses suggests we consider certain types and subtype groups as scoring "less liberal" or "more liberal" than other comparison type groupings.  This pattern, however, was different in the cluster analyses where, e.g., Republicans provided clearly conservative responses and Democrats provided clearly liberal responses.

 

A final characteristic of participants' scores involved the general tendency for scores on the social measures to be more liberal, on average, than the scores on the economic measures.  Further, the distribution of the economic scores was more uniform across the economic measures whereas the distribution of scores for the social measures clearly was skewed toward liberal responses. Also interesting: in those analyses where the assumption of equal variances across type groupings were met, the analyses involved the economic measures.  These results may be specific to this sample due to the timing of the study during which the sample data was collected; i.e., the study was conducted during the week preceding the 2008 U.S. presidential election when worsening economic conditions clearly were salient.  Thus, it is important to keep in mind that this study is a one-shot case study and that these economic and social differences might not be obtained under more normal economic conditions. Regardless, however, the results do indicate how the different types and subtypes responded during these kinds of conditions.

 

 

Analyses

 

Type Dichotomies.  We used regression analysis and the General Linear Model "Multivariate" procedure to test the effects of preference dichotomies. We used this approach given recent empirical and theoretical work suggesting that type effects are more likely to result from the individual type dichotomies alone or in additive relationships.

 

The results from this analyses focusing on the relationship between individual type preferences and political orientations showed a fairly consistent relationship between the S-N and T-F preferences, and political orientations. The regression analyses demonstrated that these preference dichotomies each were significantly related to overall political orientations such that participants with S and T preferences, on average, scored less liberal than did participants with N and F preferences.  More specific regression analyses--focusing on the Social and Economic Attitudes measures--suggested that the S-N preferences had a stronger relationship with Social Attitudes whereas the T-F preferences had a  stronger relationship with Economic Attitudes.

 

Although the type preferences only explained a little less than 10% of the variance in general political orientation, these results were theoretically meaningful and consistent with prior research (both in terms of the nature of the relationships as well as the proportion of variance explained).  From the theoretical viewpoint, both in terms of political philosophy as well as political psychology, it should come as no surprise that Sensing preferences correlated with political conservatism whereas Intuition preferences correlated with political liberalism. For example, consider the following quotes from Russell Kirk, a prominent conservative political theorist:

 

  • "Conservatives are champions of custom, convention, and continuity because they prefer the devil they know to the devil they don’t know."
  • "The conservative is not opposed to social improvement, although he doubts whether there is any such force as a mystical Progress, with a Roman P, at work in the world."
  • "Knowing human nature for a mixture of good and evil, the conservative does not put his trust in mere benevolence. Constitutional restrictions, political checks and balances, adequate enforcement of the laws, the old intricate web of restraints upon will and appetite—these the conservative approves as instruments of freedom and order."

 

Further, consider this contrast between conservatives and "progressives" provided by conservative David Horowitz in his book Radical Son :

 

  • "...conservatism [is] an attitude about the lessons of the actual past. By contrast, the attention of progressives [is] directed toward an imagined future."

 

Each of these quotes reflects the Sensing types' preferences for experience, tradition, practicality, what is, and the tried-and-true. Implicit in these quotes also is a concern about "mystical Progress" and an "imagined future" which reflects the Sensing types' view of the Intuitive types' preferences for change, imagination, the future and what could be (possibilities).

 

Inherent in the conservative's view of change is not so much opposition to change (as noted in the quote above from Kirk), but a cautious approach to change.  Certainly some of this caution arises from Edmund Burke's reaction to the dynamics of the French Revolution. (Burke often is referred to as the father of modern conservative thought. And, interestingly, he uses the notion of temperament when considering political change).  Conservatives also have the history of various Marixist revolutions and their consequences as models of the results of zealous change in the service of various "social justice" issues: liberté, égalité, fraternité. Again, however, the conservative orientation is not one opposed to change, but one opposed to imprudent change.  

 

At this point it may be worthwhile to note that we are framing our discussion of liberal and conservative politics and their relationship to psychological type preferences in terms of what may be termed traditional conservatism (!) and new liberalism (!).  It is a truism with words that their meanings evolve and take on different meanings at different times and in different places. For example, recent political discourse has witnessed the emergence of the terms paleoconservative and neoconservative,  and political philosophy makes distinctions between classical liberalism and the new liberalism. Our conceptualization here of conservatism and liberalism thus are referencing the "old conservatism" about which Burke and Kirk write, and the "new liberalism" that is more in keeping with the practiced politics of today's Democratic party. 

 

So, what is a "new liberal" and how might preferences for Intuition incline one to such a political orientation?  Our suggestion is that one answer to these questions can be found in the focus that political philosophy places on the notion of autonomy, and the numerous studies showing a positive correlation between continuous scores for Intuition and various psychological scales measuring needs for independence and autonomy (see the 1985 Manual).  Given this focus on autonomy, the "new liberal" really is not that new.  Rather, the notion of autonomy politically is a part of the evolution of "Modernity" out of the Middle Ages and thus reflects the forces at work during the Renaissance, the Enlightenment , the Protestant Reformation and so on.  Indeed, the very names and themes of these historical periods imply intuition at work: inspiration, imagination, originality, creativity.  Further, the political connotations of autonomy as a self-reflexivity that reasons free of the influence of tradition--and manifests in such philosophical acts as the hermeneutical act--implies intuitive preferences to the extent that such interpretive reasoning requires one to look at different possibilities where word is treated as symbol (or sign).

 

This autonomous inclination of the Intuitive's preference to challenge tradition provides one rationale for our finding that Intuitives, on average, scored more liberal on the measure of Social Attitudes than did the Sensing types. That is, our participants with S preferences, on average, were more likely to agree with the following statements than our participants with N preferences: 

 

  • The Bible is the actual Word of God and is to be taken literally, word for word.
  • This country would have many fewer problems if there were more emphasis on traditional family ties.
  • The newer lifestyles are contributing to the breakdown of our society.

 

As can be seen, each of these statements contains key topics that frequently are associated with Sensing preferences: a literal approach to life, a preference for tradition, and a concern about the "new".  Further, given the moral tone of the questions in the Social Attitudes measure, it seems reasonable to ask: "Are the S types more inclined to be social conservatives--and N types social liberals--within the context of the 'culture wars' that have played out in U.S. society and politics over the past 30 years?".   Research into the relationship between psychological type and religion provides some support for a "yes" answer to this question. For example, the general theme of results provided from research by Francis is reflected in this quote from one of his works:


  • A sample of 315 adult churchgoers completed an index of conservative Christian belief together with the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire and the MBTI. Christians who prefer sensing and thinking are more inclined to hold traditional beliefs than Christians who prefer intuition and feeling.

 

Such findings, when combined with our above discussion, provide further support for the hypothesis that S preferences are related to more conservative political orientations whereas N preferences are related to more liberal political orientations.

 

Results for the T-F preferences also showed a significant relationship between these type preferences and political orientations.  As shown in the results for the regression analyses, participants with T preferences reported less liberal political orientations, on average, that did participants with F preferences.  When regressed against the Social and Economic Attitudes measures, the T-F preferences were more significant in predicting Economic Attitudes with T participants again reporting more conservative orientations than F participants.

 

A look at some of the items from the Economic Attitudes measure provides one perspective for interpreting these results:

 

  • The government should see to it that every person has a job and a good standard of living.
  • The government should do more to ensure everyone has an equal chance.
  • The government should intervene to reduce income differences.

 

These items clearly reflect attitudes that support government intervention in the economy that fit well with Democratic policy making that seeks to ensure some sense of égalité regarding economic conditions.  Moreover, as evidenced in the recent debates about the economic "stimulus" bill, the Democrat's actions have been oriented to including in the bill such government actions as those which seek to ensure the welfare of those in society who are less fortunate economically in that the bill provided major support for unemployment and food stamp benefits--benefits that clearly reflect a humanitarian orientation.  To the extent that F preferences reflect such traits as being empathetic, warm, and concerned with satisfying peoples' needs (as well as a variety of other living critters' needs, in our experience) then the liberal tendency in Democrats' economic policy seems to reflect the expression of the Feeling preference. This rationale, of course, does not eliminate the possibility that some Thinking types also support such economic policy. For the Keynesian or neo-Keynesian Thinking type economist, economic policy that provides such government intervention can be perceived from the more impersonal viewpoint as supporting aggregate demand during a time of economic downturn.

 

Unfortunately, we have not been able to find any research that employs a psychological type perspective that treats on this topic.  Research employing the Five Factor Model of personality, however, does offer some support for our findings.  In particular, research in both Germany and Italy, as well as the United States, has shown that research participants who score higher on the measure of Agreeableness (or Friendliness) tend to identify with political parties that support such government intervention as described in the previous paragraph. To the extent that the personality trait of Agreeableness correlates with a preference for Feeling (as is shown in the 1998 Manual), then we have some support for the notion that F types are likely to express liberal economic attitudes more so than T types.

 

Neither the E-I nor the J-P preferences showed an independent relationship with political orientations.  This result may seem somewhat anomalous, especially for the J-P preferences, given that the bivariate correlations between the J-P preferences and most of the political orientation measures were significant. However, as is not unusual, the J-P preferences correlated with the S-N preferences.  Thus, the simple relationship of J-P preferences may be mitigated in the multivariate case and represented by the S-N preferences.  (The role of E-I and J-P preferences is of interest, however, when we look below at the results of the cluster analysis.) 

 

Type Groupings.  We also examined the relationship between various type groupings and the five political orientation measures.  The groupings included whole types, Jung's 8 types, mental functions groupings, temperament groupings, the S-N/J-P grouping, the T-F/J-P grouping and the E-I/J-P grouping. Results from the analyses involving these type groupings suggested that various subtype groupings were related to political orientations in theoretically meaningful ways.  Both the whole-type and 8-Jungian-types groupings showed statistically significant relationships with the political orientation measures.  Given the rather small number of the 4 SP types that were represented in these analyses, however,  the reliability of the results should be viewed with caution. Rather, the other subtype groupings had more participants and thus provided more reliable responses.

 

The mental functions groupings and the temperament groupings provided the most consistent results in that these groupings produced statistically significant effects for each of the five political orientation measures. In particular, the NF types consistently reported more liberal political orientations than did the SJ or ST combination, and also reported more liberal political orientations than did the NT types on most of the political orientation measures. 

 

What  is it about the NF mental functions group that predisposes this group to a more liberal orientation than the other groupings? We are aware of no empirical research which supports this finding in either the psychological type or FFM literature. The results from the research by Consulting Psychologists Press, however, do provide some support for this finding.  Their results showed that NFs (and INFs in particular) self-identified as Democrat (or Independent) much more so than Republican. To the extent that Democrats self-identify as politically liberal and Republicans self-identify as politically conservative, then the results in our study for the NFs makes some sense. Moreover, the results from Macdaid's1 study showing SJs were overrepresented amongst those who reported they were "extremely" or "very" conservative politically supports the less liberal orientations reported by the SJs in this study.

 

Our experience with the mental functions groups and organizational politics also provides some theoretical rationale for the results found in this poll. We have discussed this experience here, as well as here, but will summarize that discussion and apply it to liberal and conservative political orientations in this discussion. In particular, our experience with the mental functions groupings and organizational politics derives from our use of two exercises with various student and work groups. In both exercises the participants are first assigned to mental functions groups. Then they are asked to (1) "Draw something that represents your ideal organization" and then (2) "draw a situation at work that your consider to be political". Our conclusions from this experience is that "good" politics is whatever enacts the ideal organization of each mental functions group. "Bad" politics is that which frustrates the enactment of one's ideal organization, typologically defined. The ideal organization for each mental functions group thus represents various characteristics and values with which each group would like to associate. In this manner, the ideal organization represents a form of ideal management or government.

 

The general themes of the ideal organization drawings reflect key differences in assumptions about the nature of management (or government) that are key to the differences between political liberals and political conservative. These include:

  • Assumptions about human nature: Human imperfectibility (conservative) vs. human perfectibility (liberal).
  • The degree of trust in efficacy of government: More suspicious (conservative) vs. more trusting (liberal).
  • Orientations to governmental evolution: Prefer more traditional, proven institutions (conservative) vs. prefer more innovative organizations (liberal).
  • Assumptions about hierarchy: Hierarchy is the natural order wherein individualism is afforded liberty (conservative) vs. community is the source of the social contract which ensures equality (liberal).

 

This list is neither exhaustive (more here) nor are the various categories mutually exclusive. The list, however, does provide a start for exploring how the mental functions groups manifest their political orientations through their depiction of their ideal organizations, especially with respect to the ST and NF differences.

The ideal organization of the ST groups is one metaphorically summarized as "the machine". This form of organization or government emphasizes the STs preference for a traditional form of organization that has existed for millennia, from the hierarchy of the Catholic Church to that of Max Weber's conceptualization of bureaucracy as an ideal organizational type. This form of government assumes that employees/citizens not only are imperfectible (expressed somewhat as Theory X in managerial thinking and various doctrines of original sin in theology) but this assumption of imperfectibility is manifest in a respect for the law of variety wherein conservatives recognize people naturally differ in individual abilities (e.g., intelligence) that result in natural differences in classes, orders, material conditions, and thus inequality. That the STs are overrepresented in such career fields as law enforcement and the military correlates well with the managerial notion that mechanistic organization represents a command-and-control form of organization. Conservative bureaucracy's orientation to policies, procedures, rules, specialization of labor, centralization of authority and so on address the ST conservatives' organizational attempts to account for the imperfectibility of employees/citizens, provide for gradual organizational evolution through proven means, and provide for a more trusted centralization of authority via policies, procedures, and rules (as has been created through employment contracts in organizational arrangements and voting in the realm of public politics). Thus, within the ST machine we find the Sensing types' preferences for experience, tradition, and the here-and-now combined with the Thinking types' preferences for the impersonal and skeptical.

The ideal organization of the NF groups is one metaphorically summarized as an organization/government that allows for the full expression of the "human spirit". This form of organization or government emphasizes the NFs preferences involving possibilities (N) for people (F). The NFs thus value organizations that allow for creativity, imagination, and innovation along with an abiding respect, empathy, and concern for life in all its relationships. Their ideal organization is one based on the assumption that people are "perfectible" (at least in terms of human growth and development), are trustworthy (Theory Y in managerial thinking), and are best governed in a manner that allows for an ongoing dialogue that seeks consensus problem solving (equality) in the service of a community's betterment. The tendency of NFs to be overrepresented among such occupational groups as the clergy, conselling psychology, and the fine arts demonstrates the expression of NF energy in the realm of the human spirit. Power is expressed not through Weber's rationalized bureaucracy but, rather, though a social contract that emerges from the ongoing dialogue that takes place within a community of commitment and respect, and incarnates a postmodern version of Rousseau's general will of the people. Rather than the constitutional federalism of the conservative Republican's representative democracy, the NFs' ideal organization finds expression (via Fichte) in Mary Parker Follet's concept of democracy as "a great spiritual force evolving itself from men, utilizing each, completing his incompleteness by weaving together all in the many-membered community life which is the true Theophany." Thus, within the NF ideal organization we find the Intuition types' preferences for creativity and innovation combined with the Feeling types' preferences for the nurturing the whole.

 

The results from the analyses of the effects of the mental functions groupings on political orientations showed the NFs scored more liberal than the STs on 4 of the 5 measures of political orientations (Social Attitudes was the exception). In some of these analyses, however, the NFs scored as significantly more liberal than the SF and NT groups (as well as the ST group) while these groups (SF and NT) did not differ significantly from the ST groups. Based on our experience with the ideal organization exercise, we speculate that the SF and NT groupings produce ideal organizations that, while somewhat more egalitarian (or "decentralized") than the ST ideal organization, the NF orientation to egalitarianism is much more pronounced than that of the other groupings (especially when the NF group is predominantly NFP).



For example, the ideal organization for the SF groups is one metaphorically summarized as "small family" or "team". Within this organization there clearly is an emphasis on equality of the team members and respect for the uniqueness of each team member. Invariably, however, the SF groups recognize an overarching goal or authority that governs the group (and thus implies some degree of hierarchy). A couple of examples might help. In one situation, the SF group drew a key holder much as one might find in one's kitchen. The structure holding all the keys can be seen as the hierarchically organizing principle of the group. Each group member, however, drew his or her own unique key with his or her name on the key--representing the uniqueness of each member. In another situation, the SF group drew an arrow. In this case, the single head of the arrow represented the group's unity of purpose and direction. However, each member of the group also drew in their own unique portion of the tail feathers that would guide the arrow--again representing the uniqueness of each member.

 

We think these metaphorical portraits reflect validly some of the liberal and conservative differences between the mental functions groups. As with any use of metaphor, however, some aspects of a phenomenon are emphasized while others are de-emphasized.  For example, we believe the ST characterization presented above clearly emphasizes many aspects of conservatism.  On the other hand, characterizing  conservatism as mechanistic in the sense of the ST ideal organization produces something of a conundrum in that the mechanistic form of industrial organization was something that early conservatives seem to have regarded with disdain.  As discussed in Kirk's book The Conservative Mind , early conservatives viewed the rise of the industrial organization as emblematic of a growing secularism and a decline of a traditional, more agrarian and religious society. To the extent that various writers of the Romantic movement were involved in this conservative critique of industrialization (as Kirk notes), then we have the interesting hypothesis of the NF conservative, in that the Romantic movement emphasized intuition and "feeling" (N and F) over the evolving empiricism and rationality (S and T).  Such relationships deserve further investigation, as well as remind us that politics indeed may make strange bedfellows, even typologically. 

 

 

Cluster Analysis. We also performed a cluster analysis using participant responses to the October 08 poll. Cluster analysis is a statistical technique that seeks to form homogeneous clusters that differ from other clusters. Cluster analysis sometimes is refered to as "typological analysis" and thus seems quite appropriate for deriving various clusters of "political types" from our data. We performed two cluster analyses. The first extracted three clusters and the second extracted four clusters.

Unlike the above analyses (dichotomies and type groupings), the cluster analyses included participants' self identification as Republican, Democrat, or Independent. Thus, the variables included in the cluster analyses included type preferences, party identification, sex, age, and the five political orientation measures. In both the 3-cluster and 4-cluster analyses, we explored the role of type as dichotomies only (E-I, S-N, T-F, and J-P) and as mental functions groupings (ST, SF, NF, and NT) with the E-I and J-P dichotomies also included.

Results from the analyses produced both common themes and a some interesting differences. One consistent theme involved participants who identified with the Republican Party. This cluster invariably included more than 98% of the Republican participants, significantly more males than females, and the smallest proportion of F and NF types. The cluster also included a moderate proportion of T and ST type participants (with the NT types modestly represented in one analysis). As might be expected, this cluster reported conservative scores on the political orientation measures with economic conservatism being stronger than social conservatism. The proportion of Independents in this cluster ranged from about 27% to 44% depending upon the analyses. Fewer than 2% of Democrats fell into this cluster in each of the analyses.

A second theme was the tendency of the remaining clusters to be defined largely by Democrats followed by Independents. Further, the remaining clusters reported strong liberal orientations with social orientations generally more significant than economic orientations. The remaining clusters, however, differed in terms of the influence of the following variables: E-I, T-F, J-P, mental functions, and sex.

In the analyses where type preferences were included as the four separate dichotomies, two of the remaining clusters were distinguished by E or I preferences. The E cluster contained a large proportion of E participants along with a moderate proportion of participants who identified as Democrat or Independent. The E cluster also contained a moderate representation of F types (and the fewest T types) or a larger proportion of females than males (depending upon the analysis). The I cluster contained a large proportion of of the I participants and a moderate proportion of Democrats and Independents. In the four-cluster solution, the I cluster also contained a moderate proportion of females (and few males). A fourth cluster was not defined by the E-I dichotomy; rather this extra cluster contained about 1/3 of the male participants and about 1/4 of the F types (with only 1% of the T types). Party membership was not a significant influence on this group. And, in contrast to the other non-Repubican clusters, this cluster tended to express stronger economic liberalism.

In the analyses where type preferences were included as mental functions (along with E-I and J-P dichotomies), the remaining clusters largely were defined by sex and the J-P preferences, along with the mental functions grouping. The three-custer solution produced one cluster defined by a large proportion (80%) of female participants (with 0% males) and a large proportion (62%) of the NF participants. A majority (64%) of Democrat participants also were in this cluster along with about 37% of Independents. The second cluster was a male cluster (61% of male participants and 0% female) along with about 34% of the Democrat participants and 18% Independents. In the four-cluster solution, the female-Democrat-NF group split off another cluster, distinguished largely by the J-P preferences. The female-Democrat-NF cluster became a female-Democrat-NF-P group (with slightly smaller proportions of Democrat and NF participants--but with no J participants). The new cluster was a female-Democrat-J cluster. The cluster contained no males, no P types, and no Republican participants.

The foregoing discussion of the results from the cluster analyses raise at least three questions for further discussion:

  • Why did only one "Republican" cluster emerge whereas two or three "Democrat/Independent" clusters emerged?
  • Why did the E-I and J-P preference dichotomies influence the cluster formations when no significant effect was found for these preferences in the other analyses?
  • Why did participant sex influence the formation of so many clusters?


As an answer to the first question we must quote Will Rogers: "I belong to no organized political party -- I am a Democrat". This quote reflects an ongoing stereotype about Democrats, and thus Republicans, in that Republicans generally have been seen--at least over the past decade or so--as the talking-points-memo party. This characterization suggests Republicans are more unified and organized in contrast to Rogers' sarcasm suggesting that Democrats are not so organized. The correlations between participants who identify with the Republican party and their type preferences as E, S, T, and J also suggests that Republicans may have a more unified and organized political self-identity than do Democrats. Political dynamics over the past few years leading up to the 2008 U.S. presidential election would, however, seem to discredit this perspective somewhat. In particular, the Republican party clearly has become more divided as latent schisms between social conservatives, economic conservatives, neo-conservatives, and so on have become more apparent as a result of the 2008 election process. Rather, another answer to this question may come from the limitations in the distribution of the sample data. That is, given the relatively smaller proportion of participants in the poll who identified as Republican, the sample size may not be large enough to provide an opportunity for differences in this cluster to emerge (and form other Republican clusters).

Given these limitations, however, the results for the "Republican" cluster accord with the perspective of Republicans as more likely to be conservative politically and male than are Democrats. That T types and ST types are more frequently represented in the Republican cluster while F and NF types are only marginally represented seems reasonable given the liberal-conservative orientations for these types discussed above.

Our second question involves the E-I and J-P preferences. These preferences showed no significant relationships in the analyses focusing solely on the relationships between type and political orientations. Yet, these preferences played a significant role in the formation of some clusters. Why the different effects? One key to answering this question is to keep in mind that the cluster analyses included party identification whereas the other analyses did not. Further, research using the FFM suggests that personality and party identification are related such that Es and Js are likely to identify with more conservative or rightist political parties whereas Is and Ps are more likely to identify with more liberal or leftist parties. Unfortunately, these FFM results do not seem to apply in our situation given that the E-I and J-P effects are influential only in discriminating non-Republican clusters. Further, the influence is to discriminate clusters which generally contain females, Democrats, F types, and NF types. Like other results in this study, these results may be due to the distribution of the participants in the study. However, the results from the 1998 Consulting Psychologists Press study do provide an interesting perspective. In that study, INFs were the least likely of all the 16 types to self-identify as Republican and the INFJs were the most likely of all the whole types to self-identify with Democrats. ENFs did not show as clear a discrimination between party leanings with both the ENFPs and the ENFJs self-identifying almost uniformly across all three party identifications: Republican, Democrat, and Independent. When combined with the results from the cluster analyses, the implication is that (at least in the NF case) the E preference is associated with identification with a variety of parties whereas the I preference is associated with a disinclination to identify as Republican. Further, the P preference is associated with a greater willingness to identify as Independent whereas the J preference is negatively associated with Independence.

Our final question is: why did participant sex influence the formation of so many clusters?  As discussed above, the distribution of males and females varied significantly across some clusters. In particular, the Republican cluster consistently contained a larger proportion of male participants than female  participants.  In the mental functions analyses there was a clear tendency for a male-Democrat cluster to emerge separate from a largely female-Democrat-NF cluster.  Further, the J-P influence was evident only in female clusters, with 0% males in these two clusters.  One possible answer to this question, again, is that the results are indigenous to the participant pool.  Another more theoretical speculation is provided by those authors and commentators who have stereotyped the political parties in terms of the sexes.  For example, political commentator Chris Matthews has referred to the Republican Party as the "Daddy" party and the Democratic party as the "Mommy" party.  Similarly, University of California, Berkeley linguistics professor George Lakoff has referred to liberal and conservative political orientations in terms of family dynamics where liberals are framed in terms of  the "Nurturing Parent" metaphor  and conservatives are framed in terms of the "Strict Father" metaphor.


These speculations reflect an ongoing debate in the social sciences as well as the psychological type community about the "gendering" of various social and psychological constructs.  For example,  the effect of sex-role stereotyping in the realm of occupations has long been studied . Moreover, the type community has long focused on sex differences in responses to the T-F index (and the fact that 76% of females scored as F in the norming of the Form M appears to do little to assuage these concerns). Research on the role of sex in terms of party membership, attitudes toward various political issues, and voting behavior, however, suggest that there are differences along these lines both within parties by sex as well as between parties by sex.  Thus, a study with more conservative and Republican participants is needed along with studies that discriminate between sex (male and female) and gender (masculinity and femininity) as they relate to type and political orientations. The general regression results reported above further support this need for research in that males and T types, more so than females and F types, reported more conservative political orientations.

 

 

Theory-Method Considerations

 

As we have noted in various parts of our discussion, there has been an ongoing debate in the type community about  what constitutes a psychological type and how best to statistically analyze type data.  On the one hand, there are those2 who have argued for something of a "subgroup" approach where each whole type is taken as the unit of analysis (especially when using correlations as a foundation for analysis). When applied to this study, such an approach would seem to require, e.g., that our factor analysis of the political orientations measures be conducted on each of the 16 types separately, with subsequent analyses similarly constrained. To employ such an analysis would require a sample size of at least 10 responses for each of our 20 political orientation items for each of the 16 types, or 10x20x16=3600 participants. Clearly, our sample did not allow for such an examination.

 

On the other hand, there are those3 who have argued that the whole-type perspective--along with the associated notion of type dynamics--has not met the test of empirical examination.  Rather, the suggestion amongst these researchers is that type effects are most likely to occur at the level of the individual types alone or in additive combinations.  Our analyses, to some extent, have been able to test this view and the results here generally are supportive of this viewpoint.  For example, our regression analysis indicated that main effects--especially for the S-N and T-F preferences--were related to our political orientation measures in theoretically meaningful ways. Further, our tests for relationships between interactions of type variables and political orientation measures met with no success.  On the other hand, our analyses of the subgroups suggested the type preferences do combine to produce effects on political orientations.  

 

Within the context of these two consideration, we thus offer the results here as a limited examination of the relationship between psychological type preferences and political orientations.  And, hopefully the results provide suggestions for future research.  We cannot say, however, that the results provide any rigorous insight into the ongoing debate discussed above.

 

------------

1Macdaid, G. P. (1999, February). Facts from the CAPT databank. Paper presented at the Second Biennial Clinical Conference  of the Center for the Applications of Psychological Type, Gainesville, FL.

 

2Mitchell, W. D. (2000).  Cautions regarding aggregated data analysis in type research.  Journal of Psychological Type, 53, 19-30.

 

3Reynierse, J. H. (2009, January). The case against type dynamics. Journal of Psychological Type, 69(1), 1-21.

 



 




2005-2012 Politicaltypes.com
Joomla Template by Joomlashack
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack Joomla Templates
where to buy levothyroxine t3 tablets avodart overnight delivery side effects of xanax wiki do you have to be 18 to buy dramamine celadrin for dogs buy cleocin now co uk how to take aciclovir order brand levitra overnight online pharmacy tinidazole olanzapine cost comparison where can i get wellbutrin sr from how often to take nexium 40 mg cheap calan forcat apartment drugs speman tablets 100 kroger pharmacy jobs nashville consumer medicine information pariet fucidin uk next day delivery uk version of digoxin celebrex cause weight gain cialis professional results forum pilex shortage 2012 levitra brightonshop buy fucidin cream online buy cheap terramycin using pay pal citalopram now acquistare furosemide in italia order paroxetine canada nike air max 95 em honolulu valacyclovir 500 mg used information what is tamoxifen used for in bodybuilding negative side effects of water pills amitriptyline 50 mg tablets side effects costco pharmacy seroquel nizagara pills buy online recommended dosage for viagra something more powerful than viagra protonix medication coupons cheap delivery to us deltasone online where can i get cytoxan pills ampicillin over the counter drugs diclofenaco potassico o que e' where can you buy acai berry products brand cialis no script order retino a cream 0,05 cheap can you buy amitriptyline walmart alliston hours operation non generic omnicef order cialis super active tablets levlen generic price can you get zofran in the uk where to get saw palmetto in chennai topamax from mexico clozaril monthly cost online generic vasotec brand cialis for men sale in uk costco pharmacy celexa price valtrex y herpes zoster buy nootropil quick zentel suspension for children como se toma la pastilla amsa fast dramamine 40mg buy viagra sublingual capsules best online pharmacy no prescription viagra hyaluronic acid reviews minocin online ordering cipro pills online in the australia calan by mail buy over the counter tamoxifen online how to buy narcotics online legally lotensin over the counter drugs max safe dosage cialis levothyroxine weight loss clozaril uk brand name lopid visa benzac tablet sale cheap nizagara 40 mg no prescription rumalaya what does an allergic reaction to keflex look like free or low cost cardizem seagra free or low cost finast ciprofloxacin hcl 500mg tab used treat cymbalta price without insurance generic buy viagra plus pill mircette tablets online long time side effects beconase aq brand bystolic buy rxlist cymbalta drug atarax over counter buy canada no prescription for lotensin arava side effects weight gain eu online pharmacy review norvasc order canada my resources for living well trandate cheap price how to purchase proscar online current price zithromax where to buy kamagra online uk benadryl elixir rxlist depakote cost walmart american myambutol claritin from usa arava without script diclofenac sodium paracetamol tablets india acheter pas cher benzac price for cialis 10mg what is nexium 20mg tablets aleve sale canada buying orlistat in manchester purchase viagra australia cost of lozol generic for finasteride 5 mg side effects of proscar in women effexor xr online buy vitamin shoppe coupon 2010 safe to buy generic levitra super active from usa quibron-t delivery liquid depakote review buy albendazole tablets online mobic shelf life comprar januvia en argentina abilify prices walgreens paxil daily use reviews trileptal 20 mg bupropion xl buying online generic viagra reviews forum canadian pharmacy baclofen vs zanaflex back pain seroquel online purchase where to buy kamagra gold ointment there generic proventil inhaler zovirax by mail order purim usa sale cheap promethazine uk can i order suhagra no prescription in the usa l-tryptophan for depression reviews buy zyvox greece low cost overnight zofran antabuse implant available uk free viagra for sex offenders acheter batterie lithium 12v clozaril order canada celexa mg canada flomax generic drug lipitor mais barato where can i buy proscar online without a prescription cost of maxaman celadrin roche precio argentina fable 3 acheter alliance over the counter xenical buy amoxcillin without a prescription antabuse mg price american alliance of nlp cost generic lithium buying cleocin in manchester united states generic viagras xerograx 120 mg orlistat there generic form levaquin how long does it take for haldol to kick in kytril costco ordering ortho tri cyclen on line can topamax pills be cut in half can you only get biaxin on prescription buy sominex patch oakley liv sale zyvox cost canada buy finast without a script generic for actoplus metformin pharmacy can u snort pliva 433 pet meds canada metacam cheap menosan pills shallaki online cheap generic letrozole vs femara does walgreens sell viagra over the counter drugstore viagra frau wiki how long does it take for paroxetine to start working exelon patch patient reviews snovitra super power reviews and dosage how to take estrace tablets cheap viagra jelly no prescription cialis 4cpr riv 10 mg costo keppra brand order does accutane make you gain weight erythromycin side effects rash what is ophthacare buy atorlip-20 mg purchase robaxin in mexico effexor xr online shipping where to get cytotec paxil order dutasteride vs. finasteride study what is the correct dosage of lotensin abilify sales rep long term side effects of probalan what is hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tab saw palmetto tablets for acne micardis plus weight gain best place buy diclofenac floxin tablets us online adderall xr uk buy india levlen price renova toilet paper case study need ventolin prescription celexa dose for kids acheter du viagra forum i pill paxil website discount card buy atarax from canada can i get lamisil shallaki dosage too high where do i buy cialis soft adalat cc online pharmacy Purchase american dermatology association accutane generic zantac usa pharmacy sarafem prices i pill eldepryl website discount evista of canada bactrim ds dose for cellulitis methotrexate shortage 2011 buy astelin australia what category is diflucan in for pregnancy nizagara cost without insurance buy lisinopril with no rx crestor rosuvastatin wiki cialis super active buy online ireland brand advair diskus online ordering indian generics online carbozyne generic compazine paypal is bactrim better than cipro for uti cleocin next day shipping order birth control pills from canada health canada aceon recommended benadryl dose for children pilule alli pas cher zoloft and anafranil for ocd perche` si usa il coumadin seroflo 250 inhaler is used what purpose best price dilantin prevacid to buy in the canada without a prescription lotensin uk online no rx eulexin online xenical in usa female viagra limited india comprar female cialis online top 10 online acivir pills sites order lopid medication by mail where to buy clomid for men discount rumalaya gel xeloda for sale uk betapace brands india alli diet pill consumer reviews california gonorrhea treatment guidelines side effects of hydrea medication cialis edmonton western drug neurontin prednisone for humans and dogs sex power tablet for girl buy micronase visa side effects of erythromycin stearate tablets lamictal xr medication guide ordering low dose metformin us online pharmacy no prescription diakof keppra no prescription canada para que se usa diclofenac sodium nitroglycerin pills for heart attack what is confidor used for is nexium a prescription drug information buy liv 52 singapore house for sale cipro buy trazodone australia allopurinol medication cephalexin breastfeeding diarrhea topamax and cold medicine chloroquine gene delivery order viagra online reviews generic kamagra oral jelly switzerland revatio for discount how often to use combivent side effects of pioglitazone and metformin most reliable place to buy midamor online prozac usage in us retin a gel buy online uk order amitriptyline online in canada eldepryl 20mg tab what is valtrex made of kamagra looking for best price for terramycin ampicillin online lowest worldwide pharmacy flagyl er best generic alphagan sites famvir without insurance sale buy lotensin alesse no prescription buy antabuse no prescription fast delivery coming off citalopram insulin dependent diabetes and exercise ephedraxin sale bentyl costco cefixime tablets in pregnancy buying clomid online in australia zetia perth australia non prescription antivert pharmacy starlix 120 mg tablet alli coupon cvs prozac withdrawal night sweats prilosec over counter side effects silagra prix en pharmacie en france where toprol xl cuanto sale el tegretol accutane journal pictures is tamoxifen better than clomid como tomar disgrasil para adelgazar cheap promethazine free delivery indian alesse online discount erythromycin side effects in babies i pill rumalaya forte website medicamento ciprofloxacino para que sirve dapoxetine price in india side effects of prazosin 1 mg accutane canada price acyclovir zovirax price philippines mircette for sale uk buy revia astrailia snovitra super power drugs for sale formula 1 world champions estrace mg canadian rx generic bupropion usa pharmacy viagra generic 2012 drugs mexican pharmacy no prescription rumalaya gel cialis super active shelf life cipla pharma. ltd. mumbai purim baskets miami florida lowest priced clonidine aceon legal in england what is diovan medication used for eldepryl online meds trileptal medication bipolar buy omeprazole over the counter uk domperidone tablets cheap actoplus met online is amitriptyline better than citalopram speman pharmacy order trazodone australia price best non-perscription pharmacies levitra sale cheapest pill where can i buy antibiotics online uk buy doxycycline 15mg online anti anxiety medication uk permethrin cats safe best foundation for dry skin and good coverage buy brand nitrofurantoin is there a generic for propecia in the us cefixime express canada nymphomax next day delivery how to take eurax mg generic coreg for sale on line atrovent with american express allegra generic form amoxil antibiotics used buy levitra super active from canada buy benzac without rx capsulas de xerograx zetia from india buy paxil pills online pharmacy direct sydney australia penegra australia price grifulvin fast usa where can i get a prescription for propecia tadacip usa sale cefixime oral suspension ip taxim-o stromectol uk next day delivery price of viagra in malaysia norvasc medication side effects rabeprazole tablets india buy mobic visa define percocet addiction can i use just nolvadex for pct buy augmentin with no rx prilosec online ordering buy didronel online from usa accutane australia cost what is florinef acetate where to buy medrol in canada safely avapro discount voucher maxaman cheap price how to take atarax vytorin and grapefruit juice bactrim lowest price original cialis pills ashwagandha mg buy anafranil for ocd reviews buy cheap rosuvastatin pills mentax roche precio argentina canadian prescriptions cheaper propecia lawsuit commercial post cycle therapy actonel periactin mg buy can you get pregnant while taking metformin and provera betnovate c skin cream uses tegretol medicine moduretic from buy tadacip cheap no alcohol flagyl can you buy phenergan from boots plavix coupons discounts entocort 3mg tablets erythromycin tablets on line to buy low price tegretol uk what are the side effects of isotretinoin naprosyn 1000 mail order generic remeron viagra samples uk para que es amantadina can you still buy primatene mist over the counter medicine abana himalaya ayurvedic where can i order arimidex terramycin for sale australia remeron drugs online purchases benicar 40 mg canada free coupon for nitroglycerin cialis professional tablets from buy oregon state police jobs micronase to buy from europe vytorin cost in canada periactin generic release date buy plendil in australia order non generic elimite acai berry class action lawsuit viagra wikipedija canadian medrol cialis online cheap no prescription viagra from boots erythromycin uses dogs noroxin tablets uses recommended dose of topamax for migraines fda approved drugs in canada how long does it take for sinemet to start working new alliance east hartford maximum recommended dose of cialis cost of lamisil tablets where to buy flying mounts alliance could yasmin birth control for sale prescription drug cardizem cd zocor limited india flomax relief mr side effects top 10 online cefadroxil sites what is the difference between prednisone and anabolic steroids buy sominex no prescription order ranitidine uk viagra results before and after strattera online uk list of tesco stores selling isoptin buy deltasone uk generic cod canada drug services of kansas cheap kamagra uk reviews gmp what are the long term side effects of prilosec otc buy diovan online overnight danazol brand positioning abilify discounts coupons nizagara order in the us buy flomax next day shallaki brand positioning levaquin dosage 1000 mg buy arava boots pharmacy anacin suppliers overseas propranolol medication overnight delivery cheap genuine hydrea online best generic trileptal sites extendaquin roche precio argentina what is ashwagandha pills used for tadacip medication exelon generic cheap costs augmentin prices usa prednisone steroids and alcohol cheapest place to buy hytrin purchase cialis jelly pills buy antibiotics online next day delivery safe lamisil no prescription brand levitra spain what are side effects of cialis buy generic avandamet online how much will meclizine cost how much is amitriptyline tablets how expensive is generic zofran zerit australia price mestinon where to get bactrim forte ulotka buy kamagra online india generic viagra kamagra oral jelly pas cher italie buy acai berry juice in singapore lisinopril prescription assistance lasix without a prescription from australia lamisil to buy in the uk without a prescription allegra vs zyrtec weight gain canadian decadron sildenafil 100mg price calvin s club juniors buy glucophage 80 mg online overnight buy cheap accutane purchase trial erection packs 1 on line in canada articles on malegra fxt where to buy kamagra gold in canada safely can abilify be taken alone without an antidepressant overnight vpxl best place to order torsemide in us cymbalta without rx trazodone hydrochloride drug class can i order celexa online promethazine suppository shelf life premarin over the counter side effects of valsartan and hydrochlorothiazide staxyn gasex order aa lithium batteries for sale no rx strattera online order venlor online uk plavix online cialis mauritius can order prometrium online order zithromax medication by mail better than malegra dxt alesse order on web periactin noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy cheapest sumycin generic tetracycline best place buy pletal pct what is viagra used for drugs metformin 1000 mg tablets prograf medication side effects can you nizoral at cvs safe place to buy browser stats uk purchasing cozaar online maxalt for men sale in uk mexican pharmacy no prescription acai india online pharmacy valium order norvasc without prescription buy trinessa online no prescription danger of mixing cialis and viagra generic keflex buy canada como usar exelon patch tetracycline fda approved to buy without prescription alli over the counter prescription xenical cardura suppliers overseas buy cordarone from india buy furosemide online reviews buy rosuvastatin online safely buy azulfidine online no prescription us how much is voltaren gel without insurance cheapest carafate to buy brand cialis from australia flomax international new zealand provera buy on line zenegra new zealand blopress 100mg cheap safe place order cialis super active paroxetine cr prices pletal suppliers overseas levlen from usa ditropan tablets 150 mg generic brand buy advair diskus lasix drugstore.com imitrex pills comprar lithium en argentina safe pariet no prescription liv costs disclosure statement buy shallaki in singapore cheap arimidex sale uk how much is cytotec without insurance buy allegra tablets usa generic zyprexa for sale generic singulair where to get pamelor pct exelon where to purchase discount atorlip-5 mg order advair diskus online no prescription with a echeck side effects of augmentin in toddlers finpecia usa no prescription diakof next day amitriptyline supplier in uk best light coverage drugstore foundation what does cialis do for men without ed xenical online rx drug prescription unisom suppositories buy para que es el antifludes pediatrico pharmacies alphagan eye drops discount japanese viagra generic for pyridium can u buy doxycycline over the counter benemid express canada buy differin gel uk cialis trial pack viagra levitra prednisolone buy online+paypal can you buy acivir pills over the counter chloromycetin medicine children zofran generic reviews saleonlinedrugs zyrtec generico online absolute pharmacy puerto rico ultra low dose aceon prescription prevacid same over counter donde comprar nootropil can you buy viagra sublingual in ireland cialis overnight shipping side effects of cytoxan treatment generic ranitidine paypal motrin generic form where do i allopurinol in canada us online pharmacy no prescription gyne-lotrimin finax comprar lamictal pas cher nexium 40 mg tablets used cheap generic prednisolone no prescription antibiotic buy bactroban chloroquine in the uk coming off sertraline after 3 weeks how to use maxalt cardizem without prescription pills how to take hydrochlorothiazide what is lithium for bipolar order tadalis sx lowest price without up zyvox online valtrex uk online online pharmacy erexin-v where can i buy alligator meat in ct tamoxifen drug delivery ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics dosage carbozyne online usa no prescription lamisil without rx maxaman where can i buy it voli low cost per larnaca cipro yasmin precio mexico 2012 over the counter claritin viagra soft canada overnight delivery buying tricor in manchester purchase baclofen canada meclizine motion sickness pills levitra professional tablets on line to buy buy atarax tablets australia can we trust zaditor online buy roaccutane in uk online vermox+europe pharmacy costa rica no prescription safe tamoxifen buy toprol xl tablets donde puedo comprar voveran sr order glucophage online uk generic diclofenac gel india overnight pharmacy levlen care your skin after accutane canadian drugstore tampa fl buy minocin online no prescription cost of crestor at costco buy trandate overseas allopurinol tablets 300mg buy norvasc no prescription fast delivery nexium drug canadian pharmacy cialis jelly online without rx order nolvadex from canada zanaflex pharmacy coupons chloramphenicol order on web what is the best diet pills to lose weight fast leukeran on line no script ventolin 10 mg chloramphenicol generic release date health canada himplasia voltaren without prescription pills how long does fluoxetine take to work purchase pariet 20mg online motrin capsules midamor where to get zantac canada pharmacy shatavari next day can you get diflucan over the counter in canada how to take cytotec 200 mg buyers of kamagra gold canada retino ac gel usage can you buy toprol xl medicine doxycycline alcohol malaria spray viagra for men yasmin saleh facebook para que se usa elocon genesis today acai 100 reviews omifin 50 mg en hombres buy augmentin cheap generic antibiotics comprar la viagra natural innopran xl from canadian pharmacy best alternatives to viagra buy illegal drugs online uk amitriptyline dosage dose saw palmetto lawsuit canada over the counter medicine vpxl anti anxiety drugs over the counter low dose cialis daily use cheap levaquin mg asacol tablets discontinued buy flonase online prednisone for sale canada alli diet pills in stock kd pathak adalat wiki decadron online forum can i get lexapro free buying cialis professional for dogs tetracycline generic mexico orlistat dosage diabetes cialis wiki answers side effects of using prednisone in dogs donde comprar las bayas de acai indian generics online flonase list of tesco stores selling nimotop can i get high off allegra d can you order seroflo inhaler buy chlamydia pills online generic dutasteride canada current price flagyl er viagra women price india non prescribed medication for anxiety what is triamterene 37.5mg/hctz 25mg used for famvir drugstore.com omifin tabletas para hombres is it safe to order cardizem what is metformin used to treat what does detrol la do order actos canada generic pioglitazone order fertomid tablets spironolactone buy online uk get renagel toronto cheap genuine lotrisone online etodolac sell at counter trimox tablets online wellbutrin sr 10 mg cost over the counter medicine ditropan female viagra uk levaquin brand positioning can i buy cialis over the counter in the uk buy levothroid 50 femara generic equivalent ginseng sale philippines levitra plus non prescription what is siberian ginseng root extract phentermine canadian pharmacy no prescription cheap lipothin sale uk buy stromectol 40 recommended dosage lamictal xr astelin 40 mg pharmacy revia prices buy tinidazole 200 lipitor 100mg cheep acheter tadapox best price for toradol diakof medication metoclopramide pregnancy side effects buy atacand 40 lozol tablets side effects l-tryptophan for men sale in uk best site to buy metoclopramide duphalac medication para que se usa el medicamento augmentin generic amantadine india number pharmacies sri lanka fosamax dosage too high clear blue pregnancy test calculator brand advair diskus for sale best online pharmacy generic anacin adalat medication on line biaxin xl 500mg reviews cheapest hoodia to buy buy deltasone pills online atrovent nebulizer package insert januvia 50 mg tablet cicloferon crema cheap fedex buy elavil online where to buy zithromax azithromycin non prescription colored contact lenses for dark brown eyes buy nexium online no prescription esomeprazole buy cialis super active mexican pharmacies yasmin bayer precio mexico plus no prescription levitra online erexin without prescription brahmi over counter uk wellbutrin sr mg canadian rx trial erection packs 1 on line oregon state treasury office do hyaluronic acid cause weight gain can you buy doxycycline over counter where is james arthur off x factor from can you order prednisone deltasone treatment cheap vasotec usa zolpidem 10mg mevacor tablets side effects tadapox online unicure conditioner order ortho tri cyclen online shallaki coupon code zithromax cheap india pharmacy purchase accutane 80 mg where can i buy clomid cheap comprar haldol pela internet can you buy nizagara in ireland free online pharmacy tricor online buying promethazine using paypal femara online india how long does it take for propranolol to work for anxiety cheap alavert sale uk ordering aciphex ephedraxin where to get free or low cost keftab can you open hytrin capsules elocom crema furoato de mometasona citalopram online australia viagra soft gel capsules genuine reglan 100mg buy yagara hong kong provera without perscbion cialis soft discount no prescription micardis dosage too high purchase actos 45 mg purchase generic canadian alesse online pharmacy free shipping brand amoxil drug class dapoxetine purchase uk amantadine prices cvs levitra dosage 5mg flagyl generic mexico healthy weight management program non prescription duetact buy thyroxine online uk best place to buy atorlip-20 how to by aricept online mail order generic isoptin order atarax lowest price how can i make homemade viagra finpecia cipla goa endep drug class proscar pills online in the mexico oral methotrexate side effects ortho tri cyclen lo buy online no prescription buy viagra brisbane australia cozaar for sale philippines black market viagra toronto cipla pharma company paxil 20 mg film tablet caverta australia price buy zyloprim online with mastercard ditropan online in us where is the cheapest avamigran pill flight search engines paxil cr for anxiety reviews cuvarlix orlistat 120 mg acheter cialis sans prescription roaccutane wiki what is a clomid challenge test lithium motorsports coupon code low cost overnight valtrex coumadin medication what is vardenafil hcl 20 mg buy purinethol singapore buy strattera patch sertraline withdrawal brain zaps wellbutrin sr online in usa elavil on line in the uk januvia metformin xr symptoms lexapro dose too high buy lanoxin online india zentel worm medicine side effect valtrex cheap uk vegetal vigra ebay is there a generic drug for paxil can i make caverta cheap bactroban 40 mg what drug category is lasix comprare propecia in italia can fluoxetine hydrochloride get you high buy digoxin online no prescription us mobic buy on line amlodipine besylate tablets buy lamictal in uk red ginseng pills user reviews for periactin iv brand beconase aq for sale antivert pharmacy what is cialis drugs staxyn reviews waheed alli net worth without actoplus met is it possible to buy with paypal on amazon buy aceon in australia best erectile dysfunction pills cialis jelly drug in usa pharmacy effexor vs zoloft weight gain us online pharmacy no prescription cipro voveran online cheap aspirin for sale ireland floxin max dose nitroglycerin with paypal payment the online drugstore ditropan pariet for sale online rumalaya with american express iantd trimix course cheap aldactone 100mg antabuse on line implicane 50mg canada and levothroid cipro new zealand celebrex discount medications naprosyn without a script better than caverta purchasing tadacip online uk cefixime prescription bacterial infections ear what is the dosage for compazine buy viagra sublingual overseas buy generic arimidex online no prescription where to buy cheap generic kamagra chewable zofran 4mg tablets pregnancy chloromycetin spain trental order on web neo medrol canada do hyaluronic acid pills work when does zyvox go generic simvastatin drug contraindications nombre de viagra para mujeres benicar online pharmacy uk alesse birth control buy online minocycline online in usa overnight controlled drug pharmacy computer discount via cipro roma Purchase viagra 10 mg luvox pas cher italie aciphex without prescriptions keftab for sale online solubility enhancement of poorly water soluble drug generic vs brand name wellbutrin xl where to buy confido ointment buy lipothin australia qsymia online no prescription generic coreg cr 40 mg elocon direct pharmacy buy generic pilex online flagyl 500 mg dose kamagra oral jelly fast delivery amantadine mail order india purchase carafate suspension buy inderal online no prescription us buy apcalis sx in singapore plendil dosage too high buy strattera next day non prescription brafix pharmacy how to buy bactroban in london trazodone online no prescription propranolol for sale australia terramycin bonus pills buy vantin visa order noroxin online in usa order procardia cheap side effects of zanaflex can i buy plavix from canada buy methotrexate philippines clonidine patch for hot flashes prednisolone 5mg tablets cats what types of sarafem are there amaryl m1 dose fertomid tablets on line to buy cefixime 200 mg during pregnancy buspar anxiety worse kamagra oral jelly online in usa vega 100 tablets use in urdu indocin for men sale in uk where to buy hydrea in canada safely over the counter order avapro online viagra jelly overnight shipping cheap glimepiride tablets side effects side effects aciclovir 800mg tablets aciclovir where can i buy it desyrel india buy tadacip 20 mg isoniazid dosage renal failure uk version of diovan pravachol tablets from buy bentyl medication classroom dipyridamole pharmacy order atrovent drug oversea over counter suhagra uk pharmacies online that sell luvox what is procardia xl used for buspar for anxiety and panic attacks red viagra cialis - 200 mg ginseng mg buy etodolac mg tablet ditropan pills drugstore buy fucidin online reviews cefixime 400 mg cheap online januvia online forum fast yasmin deleviery cialis vs viagra price anxiety symptoms yahoo cialis soft fast canada what is medrol used for canadian cialis soft cystone pas cher cheap cafergot pills amoxicillin trihydrate 500 mg side effects discount zyprexa mg canadian tadalis sx tablet buy dimenhydrinate uk acheter furosemide pas cher one guy one cup official video buy benzac 200 order ethionamide tablets mycelex-g delivery london order silagra uk pharmacy europe drugs statistics fenofibrate class action lawsuit ventolin side effects long term use where to buy saw palmetto in ireland where can i buy acai berry in stores famvir order by phone nizagara pharmacy online eurax tablets online elavil for sale usa prednisolone medication on line how long to use prednisolone dadha pharmacy buy celebrex online with no perscription doxycycline reviews acne review lasix m tablets side effects canadian online pharmacy for acai torsemide on the internet drug market order orlistat cost of fertomid buy nymphomax 20 purchase norvasc 5mg cheap metformin canada generic januvia price uk pill rx health ditropan products buy 40 mg accutane cheap prednisone dose costochondritis order imitrex injection cheap astelin pills where to buy nimotop lopid for sale online united support solutions doxazosin order online no prescription pfizer viagra discount pill order erection packs 1 package phone in order for brand levitra evista daily use reviews order nitrofurantoin canada buy haldol paypal accepted risperdal prescription medicine where could i buy medrol without prescription how long does it take to see results from orlistat what rock is made of calcium carbonate buy bentyl dicyclomine order trandate 120 mg lipitor sale us isoptin 240 mg sr online pharmacy mobic buy brand levitra singapore tramadol dosage bluelight what does a prednisone 20 mg tablet look like how to take provera medicine order ethionamide canada coolock artane credit union opening hours roxithromycin without prescription lamisil online no prescription generic cabana himalaya medicine cialis over counter mexico cialis originale quanto costa rumalaya no prescription canada post cycle therapy eurax lipitor generics in south africa cost of zovirax without insurance purchase neurontin lowest price how to order levitra super active zyprexa tablets uses cheap ralista sale uk clonidine dosage for sleep ordering zoloft canada liquid purim review do i need a prescription for bupron sr top 100 pharmaceutical companies in india advair diskus purchase luvox online no prescription azithromycin chlamydia drinking alcohol national american miss amaryllis best site to buy flomax colchicine on line in the usa alli diet pill in australia canadian pharmacy skelaxin can you buy retino-a cream 0,025 over the counter in germany allegra 120 price in india buy dutas perth australia valtrex discount prices online how to use levlen birth control fosamax price australia renagel uk manfaat obat bactrim forte effexor online pharmacy shipped to canada hyzaar now doxycycline to buy in england buy generic viagra melbourne buy abana tablets online xenical canada online clomid prices cheap geriforte syrup pills what is lexapro used for in children buy mirapex boots pharmacy what are the side effects of levaquin antibiotic diuretics water pills side effects apo amoxicillin 500mg alcohol vermox next day delivery buy lincocin discount order zebeta pulmicort nebulizer pediatric dose david rosenblatt arava power company online rumalaya purchase is zyban legal in uk provera 2.5 mg tab tretinoin cream buy online uk topamax discount vouchers acheter voltarene en ligne walgreens discount card prescriptions buy probalan singapore is generic crestor available in usa snorting ambien side effects is evecare legal in uk can buy propecia over counter acivir pills purchase in canada no prescription azithromycin doxycycline buy rhine river incident what is keppra medication why has keftab been discontinued prandin side effects plendil usa sale where to purchase triamterene atorlip-10 weight gain primatene mist inhaler ingredients bactrim online store purchase rhinocort online azithromycin buy online australia ambien 10 mg fda seroflo inhaler dosage buy viagra overnight delivery tretinoin 0,025 delivery london order renagel without rx metformin 40 mg pharmacy generic tetracycline safe what is tadalafil medications relafen online pharmacy uk cheap viagra tablets canadian pharmacy canadian online pharmacy for eldepryl current price compazine buy mobic 15mg online drugs containing amitriptyline januvia sales 2012 is it illegal to order generic mycelex-g what is lasix pills used for generic levitra canadian pharmacy reputable online pharmacy no prescription needed cheap levaquin 250 mg florida benfotiamine order propecia 5 mg where to buy prograf ointment how to purchase alli generic celexa overnite shipping buy ventolin hfa inhaler generic proventil hfa inhaler buy actos online prescription anafranil tablets uk desyrel no prescription overnight delivery clomid medication fertility betnovate n cream side effects metformin with benfotiamine tablets use buy differin 200 procardia online without prescription kroger pharmacy 4 dollar drug list levaquin how to take with food betapace lawsuit canada rumalaya liniment mg tablet can you buy duphalac what types of fucidin are there levitra without script billig lopressor online kaufen buy elimite online amazon where to buy ashwagandha root danazol drug information quiero comprar requip betnovate n cream uses zestril uses haridra india robaxin coupons salep bactroban mupirocin fluoxetine from teva robern med cabinet yasmin consumer medicine information free or low cost clozaril safe site to by trazodone usual proventil dosage renagel 800 tab clomid medication side effects a typical aspirin tablet contains 324 mg of aspirin paroxetine 10 mg for premature ejaculation liv 52 doses side effects of tofranil in children long term side effects of minomycin buy viagra online cheap to uk isoptin costco generic uk paypal indinavir discount pet medications canada mail-order baclofen ciplox reviews and dosage cheap xenical free delivery combivent udvs nebuliser solution cleocin t fiyat no prescription fast alli buy online pamelor generic reviews zantac tablets uses ventolin hfa side effects long term generic plavix in canada moduretic express canada indian pharmacy aleve amitriptyline low blood sugar medication is plavix generic yet lowest price glucotrol xl finax for sale online phenergan tablets 25mg picture nootropil 1200 mg tabletta arava 20 mg prices lilly cialis tablets generico del bactrim buy viagra online safely eulexin pills sweat amoxicillin powder for oral suspension ingredients abilify online usa discount canadian pharmacy alphagan how to order acai burn can you buy ophthacare over the counter cvs crestor price us online pharmacy clomid effexor xr online prescription amaryl medication for sale zovirax cream best online pharmacy technician program accutane diary mild acne how to use shatavari ghee order nizoral online canada canadian online pharmacy generic cialis 100mg quickest protonix purchase rocaltrol order alligator tail medicine lanoxin used is lopressor a prescription drug diclofenac gel buy online ireland can i order tenormin no prescription in the usa rosuvastatin tablets formulation diflucan dosage for candida yasmin buy without prescription viagra online next day delivery drugstore buy acticin strattera generic canada best online pharmacy usa generic what is the classification for coreg buy dapoxetine from canada cost of depakote without insurance where can i get diflucan online can buy apcalis sx online can you buy doxycycline in vietnam carafate without script prednisona alonga 10 mg para sirve what is estradiol used for in ivf cleocin gel no rx aldactone with no perscription can you take viagra while drinking alcohol half price benadryl brand viagra 10 mg ephedraxin direct pharmacy where to buy malegra fxt in canada safely imitrex lawsuit benicar cost walmart what does augmentin look like how to order diclofenac buy online viagra absolute buy meds without a prescription purchase actos 4 30mg how to buy 1 month xbox live gold online increasing returns to scale graph generic lexapro no perscription new information on keppra and pregnancy zithromax z-pak for sinus infection asacol hd price clomid prix en pharmacie en france cheap protonix pills zofran morning sickness uk american express platinum login australia cheap ephedraxin 40 mg coumadin capsules can you buy viagra jelly in ireland amaryl overnight delivery rx required avalide on line for sale no script cialis sublingual canadian pharmacy dipyridamole mr capsules purchase chloromycetin pills online ethionamide purchase rhinocort online in us ophthacare tablets from buy gabapentin withdrawal symptoms sleep how to use forzest 20 ivermectin scabies cost purchase generic hyzaar yasmin online in uk buy green xanax bars online allopurinol medication interactions zyloprim buy albendazole patch trial erection packs 1 tablets zyprexa visa brand viagra canadian source can order rumalaya liniment canada montemax montelukast side effects cefixime pill shortage cymbalta shopping motilium online meds micronase no prescription needed keftab over the counter furosemide lasix drug classification long term side effects of zoloft protonix drug in canada pharmacy buy doxazosin uk buy cheap lopressor famvir dosage for herpes walmart pharmacy augmentin cost norvasc refills how much does lexapro cost without health insurance buy silagra 50 cystone where can i buy it flomax relief boots uk version of combivent solu medrol 40 mg the online drugstore cyklokapron generic prometrium no prescription zenegra for daily use canada trental drugs for sale actoplus met australia pharmacy clavamox 500 kalbe farma over the counter alternative to cipro how to take premarin sominex tablets online remeron by mail order sominex from india ceftin generic release date buy amitryptryline most reliable place to buy plavix online where can i buy alli tablets buy viagra online debit card afectos adversos sertralina retin a or retin a micro nystatin and triamcinolone acetonide cream uk viagra soft 100 review hay pastillas para abortar zenegra 100mg cheap triderm krema se koristi buy anacin in uk arimidex pharmacy online nitrofurantoin medication online best brand prices prescription viagra online pharmacy that sells trazodone lithium tablets versus capsules proscar recommended dosage cialis online cheap from canada buy indinavir vermox suspension medicine buy zoloft with no prescription is celexa available in canada what is toprol xl 50 mg used for cialis paypal bestellen tetracycline 500 canada little blue pill pharmacy what is gyne-lotrimin pills used for what is viagra like watermelon acquistare vpxl in italia testosterone therapy for women benefits evecare perth australia what is the generic for carafate serevent where can i buy it cheap kamagra supplier discount code revia medicine us pharmacies online that sell nizoral aciclovir shortage 2012 where can i purchase trazodone levitra pharmacy canada cheapest drug nolvadex clomid australia buy buying viagra online with paypal online no prescription uk escitalopram buy benzac tablets for sale how to take bactroban lisinopril discontinued order procardia xl can you buy brand cialis over the counter in germany pletal billig kaufen raloxifene tamoxifen side effects clorfenamina compuesta mentat ds syrup over counter purchase atarax lowest price over the counter buy avapro prescription lowest price minipress viagra sublingual sale generic pills fastest lasix uk delivery how do i buy liverpool fc tickets erythromycin drug schedule prescription buy generic amaryl online mexican pharmacy no prescription carafate generic cardura for sale on line can tricor tablets be crushed finast from europe pfingstferien bayer 2013 overnight pharmacy bupron sr view topic canadian reviews on mobicam digital glucotrol xl tablets uses vermox usa drugstore buy online order diarex diamox drug store online what drug category is levlen how to use vega 100 tablets can you buy citalopram online are cipla drugs safe cialis cost of benazepril hydrochlorothiazide cialis tablets for sale uk cipla price viagra egypt what is prednisone prescribed for in dogs can you buy flovent mcg fluticasone is endep legal in uk low cost ginseng nitrofurantoin tablets. what are they for where is the left parietal lobe stromectol barato buy tinidazole online at canada pharmacy seroquel starting dose schizophrenia is it illegal to order generic metformin cabgolin no prescription canada buy generic voltaren online with prescription tricor from india plavix nowa cena omeprazole side effect weight gain citalopram dose in elderly depakote purchase where to carafate phenytoin online order desyrel medication by mail purchase nizoral uk discount seroquel coupons where amitriptyline prescription side effects what is erexor drugs betnovate without a script generic version of plan b cost vardenafil andorra zyban reviews 2010 rogaine 5 australia price non persciption digoxin tetracycline dogs chloroquine price india crestor ships from india comprar metoclopramide online buy piracetam uk powder ginseng non perscription countries buy oxytrol greece forum view topic purchase periactin online use emsam coupon online cleocin t gel price eurax chicken pox metoclopramide ships from india most reliable place to buy motrin online nexium canada overnight delivery doxycycline malaria effectiveness ceftin canada sale celebrex 100 mg capsule prospect how to get evista buy noroxin tablets crestor 10mg ciplox direct pharmacy ortho tri cyclen lo generic side effects how much will gasex cost sildenafil tablets dosage cost of citalopram to nhs generic pulmicort safe where could i buy ortho tri cyclen without prescription free coupon for benicar descargar pack de dragon ball z para pivot buy viagra super active without a subscription buy trileptal discount natural way of increasing sperm count doxycycline genrx tablets 100mg genuine avodart best price eurax generic release date comprar ventolin original tadacip generic cialis cheapest robaxin where to vpxl sons sol pharmacy house nitroglycerin tablets manufacturer india how to take terramycin canadian online pharmacy surrey bc rimadyl dogs wikipedia what is liv 52 used for buydrugscheap are there any over the counter drugs to cure chlamydia pfizer zithromax suspension lanoxin bonus pills luvox no prescription overnight delivery side effects of coumadin overdose buy avalide with paypal depakote er dosage forms buy deltasone discount amitriptyline without prescription pills where to buy red ginseng root buy seroflo with e check innopran xl order canada arimidex mail order buy imiquimod no prescription tamsulosin 0.4mg price alli diet pill available canada med cab diflucan new primatene mist inhaler order feldene pills can you buy desyrel over the counter in germany generic erythromycin ophthalmic 40mg nolvadex how long does it take elavil to work for anxiety differin tablets uk brand advair diskus drug schedule diovan hct dosage forms india diamox price online pharmacies in canada no prescription where is the cheapest place to buy lantus insulin reputable online pharmacies purchase actos pills order cialis 10 mg online how long does it take for lisinopril cough to go away lamictal brand order cheap actos 45 mg cheap generic best online pharmacy generic abana does singulair come in generic form promethazine hydrochloride 20 mg zantac for sale uk generic for sinequan prometrium 100mg tablet vpxl mexico cipla pharma company bangalore side effects of generic cipro comprar baclofen online comprar dapoxetine online cheap retino a cream 0 05 floxin antibiotics side effects what is xalatan drug bystolic dosage side effects amitriptyline withdrawal how long does it last buy zaditor hong kong prescription online without antibiotic cost zyvox online precose drug class how long does nizoral take to work hair loss where can i order isoptin reviews on diclofenac gel order medicine online singapore minipress tablets on line to buy better than celexa praziquantel for fish uk lotensin precio mexico effexor xr 75mg reviews does propecia work forum diltiazem online usa no prescription once daily cialis price buy kamagra uk review 100mg over the counter medicine minipress is there a generic form of aciphex can i make septilin how to take nizoral mg promethazine vc syrup shelf life duphalac for sale philippines buy cheap tamoxifen pills medicamentos celebrex celecoxib 100 mg advair diskus 250/50 price comparison topamax online meds glyset online usa carafate medication over the counter diclofenac tablets 50mg dosage micardis 40 mg tab buy bactrim online overnight shipping gonorrhea treatment antibiotics dosage methotrexate injection cost without insurance online celebrex purchase can you get high off of lisinopril 10 mg where do i buy trental does lipitor work better than zocor purchasing finpecia online uk levitra drugs online zithromax canada pharmacy buy nexium no prescription is it illegal to order generic himplasia how much is canadian health insurance geriforte syrup sold over counter prilosec canada otc triamterene for sale online what is the best acai berry diet product difference between zantac and prilosec for babies cheap alphagan 40 mg nymphomax from canada ampicillin canada overnight delivery what do allegra pills look like clorfenamina maleato para que sirve buy viagra over the counter in spain yahoo answers lipothin with raspberry ketone dr oz buy sumycin 100 fast benadryl delivery peut on acheter du viagra en belgique how to order diclofenac gel online where phenergan side effects taking metformin tablets aricept medication classification round orange bayer cross 20 best price for albendazole generic viagra fast shipping uk carbozyne online legally disfuncion erectil psicologica terapia lipitor generic prices order yagara online with visa boots midnight pharmacy kingston park side effects of extendaquin