topleft
topright

Main Menu

Home
Assessment Guidelines
Organizational Politics
Public Politics
Classroom Politics
Psychological Types
Discussion - 10/08 Results E-mail
Article Index
Discussion - 10/08 Results
Participants
Political Orientation
Analytical Strategy
16 Types
Jungian Types
Temperament
Mental Functions
TF x JP
SN x JP
EI x JP
Comments on Type Groups
Type and Demographics
Clusters
Summary Discussion
A Proposed Model
Thanks
 

 

Summary Discussion

 

 

Objectives

 

The primary purpose of the final (October 08) Type and Politics Poll was to examine in more detail the relationship between psychological type preferences and political orientations.  Prior research in both the psychological type field as well as research employing the Five-Factor Model (FFM) of personality has suggested that the S-N preferences clearly seem to be related to political orientations in terms of "liberal" and "conservative" orientations.  Most of these studies, however, have used only a single item to measure these orientations.

 

Our purpose in the final poll was to extend this research in two ways.  First, we created measures based on the assumption that there are at least two related dimensions of liberal and conservative orientations--one concerning social issues and the other concerning economic issues.  Second, we created measures to reflect participants' political self-perceptions of themselves as liberal or conservative on social and economic issues as well as measures that reported political attitudes toward economic and social issues. Our approach to liberal-conservative political orientation thus was multidimensional.  Given the various theoretical frameworks that suggest people seek cognitive consistency (or avoid cognitive dissonance) in terms of ego identity, however, we should expect these different orientations to be related (as was shown in the correlations of the five measures).

 

During our analyses we also kept in mind the ongoing debate surrounding whole types. Thus, we analyzed our data in terms of whole types (and subtypes) as well as at the level of the individual preferences.

 

 

Results

 

 

Sample

 

Before looking at the results of the analyses, it is important to keep in mind the nature of the sample upon which the analyses are based. In particular, most (66%) of the participants reported being APTi members. Thus, it should not be surprising that a large proportion of the sample members reported preferences for Intuition (77%) and were female (59%). ENFPs constituted the modal type (17%) followed by INTJs (11%) and INFPs (11%). Further, as is not unusual, the SPs constituted only a small proportion (14%) of the sample. These results suggest the subtype analyses likely are more reliable than the  whole-type analyses given that the number of observations for each subtype are larger than for the whole-type or Jungian-type analyses.

 

The tendency of the participants to score more liberal on each of the political orientation measures in the type-only analyses (i.e., those without demographics included) also should be considered.  As was shown in each of the type-only analyses, participants, on average, provided slightly liberal to more strongly liberal responses on each of the political orientation measures.  This skew of the responses suggests we consider certain types and subtype groups as scoring "less liberal" or "more liberal" than other comparison type groupings.  This pattern, however, was different in the cluster analyses where, e.g., Republicans provided clearly conservative responses and Democrats provided clearly liberal responses.

 

A final characteristic of participants' scores involved the general tendency for scores on the social measures to be more liberal, on average, than the scores on the economic measures.  Further, the distribution of the economic scores was more uniform across the economic measures whereas the distribution of scores for the social measures clearly was skewed toward liberal responses. Also interesting: in those analyses where the assumption of equal variances across type groupings were met, the analyses involved the economic measures.  These results may be specific to this sample due to the timing of the study during which the sample data was collected; i.e., the study was conducted during the week preceding the 2008 U.S. presidential election when worsening economic conditions clearly were salient.  Thus, it is important to keep in mind that this study is a one-shot case study and that these economic and social differences might not be obtained under more normal economic conditions. Regardless, however, the results do indicate how the different types and subtypes responded during these kinds of conditions.

 

 

Analyses

 

Type Dichotomies.  We used regression analysis and the General Linear Model "Multivariate" procedure to test the effects of preference dichotomies. We used this approach given recent empirical and theoretical work suggesting that type effects are more likely to result from the individual type dichotomies alone or in additive relationships.

 

The results from this analyses focusing on the relationship between individual type preferences and political orientations showed a fairly consistent relationship between the S-N and T-F preferences, and political orientations. The regression analyses demonstrated that these preference dichotomies each were significantly related to overall political orientations such that participants with S and T preferences, on average, scored less liberal than did participants with N and F preferences.  More specific regression analyses--focusing on the Social and Economic Attitudes measures--suggested that the S-N preferences had a stronger relationship with Social Attitudes whereas the T-F preferences had a  stronger relationship with Economic Attitudes.

 

Although the type preferences only explained a little less than 10% of the variance in general political orientation, these results were theoretically meaningful and consistent with prior research (both in terms of the nature of the relationships as well as the proportion of variance explained).  From the theoretical viewpoint, both in terms of political philosophy as well as political psychology, it should come as no surprise that Sensing preferences correlated with political conservatism whereas Intuition preferences correlated with political liberalism. For example, consider the following quotes from Russell Kirk, a prominent conservative political theorist:

 

  • "Conservatives are champions of custom, convention, and continuity because they prefer the devil they know to the devil they don’t know."
  • "The conservative is not opposed to social improvement, although he doubts whether there is any such force as a mystical Progress, with a Roman P, at work in the world."
  • "Knowing human nature for a mixture of good and evil, the conservative does not put his trust in mere benevolence. Constitutional restrictions, political checks and balances, adequate enforcement of the laws, the old intricate web of restraints upon will and appetite—these the conservative approves as instruments of freedom and order."

 

Further, consider this contrast between conservatives and "progressives" provided by conservative David Horowitz in his book Radical Son :

 

  • "...conservatism [is] an attitude about the lessons of the actual past. By contrast, the attention of progressives [is] directed toward an imagined future."

 

Each of these quotes reflects the Sensing types' preferences for experience, tradition, practicality, what is, and the tried-and-true. Implicit in these quotes also is a concern about "mystical Progress" and an "imagined future" which reflects the Sensing types' view of the Intuitive types' preferences for change, imagination, the future and what could be (possibilities).

 

Inherent in the conservative's view of change is not so much opposition to change (as noted in the quote above from Kirk), but a cautious approach to change.  Certainly some of this caution arises from Edmund Burke's reaction to the dynamics of the French Revolution. (Burke often is referred to as the father of modern conservative thought. And, interestingly, he uses the notion of temperament when considering political change).  Conservatives also have the history of various Marixist revolutions and their consequences as models of the results of zealous change in the service of various "social justice" issues: liberté, égalité, fraternité. Again, however, the conservative orientation is not one opposed to change, but one opposed to imprudent change.  

 

At this point it may be worthwhile to note that we are framing our discussion of liberal and conservative politics and their relationship to psychological type preferences in terms of what may be termed traditional conservatism (!) and new liberalism (!).  It is a truism with words that their meanings evolve and take on different meanings at different times and in different places. For example, recent political discourse has witnessed the emergence of the terms paleoconservative and neoconservative,  and political philosophy makes distinctions between classical liberalism and the new liberalism. Our conceptualization here of conservatism and liberalism thus are referencing the "old conservatism" about which Burke and Kirk write, and the "new liberalism" that is more in keeping with the practiced politics of today's Democratic party. 

 

So, what is a "new liberal" and how might preferences for Intuition incline one to such a political orientation?  Our suggestion is that one answer to these questions can be found in the focus that political philosophy places on the notion of autonomy, and the numerous studies showing a positive correlation between continuous scores for Intuition and various psychological scales measuring needs for independence and autonomy (see the 1985 Manual).  Given this focus on autonomy, the "new liberal" really is not that new.  Rather, the notion of autonomy politically is a part of the evolution of "Modernity" out of the Middle Ages and thus reflects the forces at work during the Renaissance, the Enlightenment , the Protestant Reformation and so on.  Indeed, the very names and themes of these historical periods imply intuition at work: inspiration, imagination, originality, creativity.  Further, the political connotations of autonomy as a self-reflexivity that reasons free of the influence of tradition--and manifests in such philosophical acts as the hermeneutical act--implies intuitive preferences to the extent that such interpretive reasoning requires one to look at different possibilities where word is treated as symbol (or sign).

 

This autonomous inclination of the Intuitive's preference to challenge tradition provides one rationale for our finding that Intuitives, on average, scored more liberal on the measure of Social Attitudes than did the Sensing types. That is, our participants with S preferences, on average, were more likely to agree with the following statements than our participants with N preferences: 

 

  • The Bible is the actual Word of God and is to be taken literally, word for word.
  • This country would have many fewer problems if there were more emphasis on traditional family ties.
  • The newer lifestyles are contributing to the breakdown of our society.

 

As can be seen, each of these statements contains key topics that frequently are associated with Sensing preferences: a literal approach to life, a preference for tradition, and a concern about the "new".  Further, given the moral tone of the questions in the Social Attitudes measure, it seems reasonable to ask: "Are the S types more inclined to be social conservatives--and N types social liberals--within the context of the 'culture wars' that have played out in U.S. society and politics over the past 30 years?".   Research into the relationship between psychological type and religion provides some support for a "yes" answer to this question. For example, the general theme of results provided from research by Francis is reflected in this quote from one of his works:


  • A sample of 315 adult churchgoers completed an index of conservative Christian belief together with the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire and the MBTI. Christians who prefer sensing and thinking are more inclined to hold traditional beliefs than Christians who prefer intuition and feeling.

 

Such findings, when combined with our above discussion, provide further support for the hypothesis that S preferences are related to more conservative political orientations whereas N preferences are related to more liberal political orientations.

 

Results for the T-F preferences also showed a significant relationship between these type preferences and political orientations.  As shown in the results for the regression analyses, participants with T preferences reported less liberal political orientations, on average, that did participants with F preferences.  When regressed against the Social and Economic Attitudes measures, the T-F preferences were more significant in predicting Economic Attitudes with T participants again reporting more conservative orientations than F participants.

 

A look at some of the items from the Economic Attitudes measure provides one perspective for interpreting these results:

 

  • The government should see to it that every person has a job and a good standard of living.
  • The government should do more to ensure everyone has an equal chance.
  • The government should intervene to reduce income differences.

 

These items clearly reflect attitudes that support government intervention in the economy that fit well with Democratic policy making that seeks to ensure some sense of égalité regarding economic conditions.  Moreover, as evidenced in the recent debates about the economic "stimulus" bill, the Democrat's actions have been oriented to including in the bill such government actions as those which seek to ensure the welfare of those in society who are less fortunate economically in that the bill provided major support for unemployment and food stamp benefits--benefits that clearly reflect a humanitarian orientation.  To the extent that F preferences reflect such traits as being empathetic, warm, and concerned with satisfying peoples' needs (as well as a variety of other living critters' needs, in our experience) then the liberal tendency in Democrats' economic policy seems to reflect the expression of the Feeling preference. This rationale, of course, does not eliminate the possibility that some Thinking types also support such economic policy. For the Keynesian or neo-Keynesian Thinking type economist, economic policy that provides such government intervention can be perceived from the more impersonal viewpoint as supporting aggregate demand during a time of economic downturn.

 

Unfortunately, we have not been able to find any research that employs a psychological type perspective that treats on this topic.  Research employing the Five Factor Model of personality, however, does offer some support for our findings.  In particular, research in both Germany and Italy, as well as the United States, has shown that research participants who score higher on the measure of Agreeableness (or Friendliness) tend to identify with political parties that support such government intervention as described in the previous paragraph. To the extent that the personality trait of Agreeableness correlates with a preference for Feeling (as is shown in the 1998 Manual), then we have some support for the notion that F types are likely to express liberal economic attitudes more so than T types.

 

Neither the E-I nor the J-P preferences showed an independent relationship with political orientations.  This result may seem somewhat anomalous, especially for the J-P preferences, given that the bivariate correlations between the J-P preferences and most of the political orientation measures were significant. However, as is not unusual, the J-P preferences correlated with the S-N preferences.  Thus, the simple relationship of J-P preferences may be mitigated in the multivariate case and represented by the S-N preferences.  (The role of E-I and J-P preferences is of interest, however, when we look below at the results of the cluster analysis.) 

 

Type Groupings.  We also examined the relationship between various type groupings and the five political orientation measures.  The groupings included whole types, Jung's 8 types, mental functions groupings, temperament groupings, the S-N/J-P grouping, the T-F/J-P grouping and the E-I/J-P grouping. Results from the analyses involving these type groupings suggested that various subtype groupings were related to political orientations in theoretically meaningful ways.  Both the whole-type and 8-Jungian-types groupings showed statistically significant relationships with the political orientation measures.  Given the rather small number of the 4 SP types that were represented in these analyses, however,  the reliability of the results should be viewed with caution. Rather, the other subtype groupings had more participants and thus provided more reliable responses.

 

The mental functions groupings and the temperament groupings provided the most consistent results in that these groupings produced statistically significant effects for each of the five political orientation measures. In particular, the NF types consistently reported more liberal political orientations than did the SJ or ST combination, and also reported more liberal political orientations than did the NT types on most of the political orientation measures. 

 

What  is it about the NF mental functions group that predisposes this group to a more liberal orientation than the other groupings? We are aware of no empirical research which supports this finding in either the psychological type or FFM literature. The results from the research by Consulting Psychologists Press, however, do provide some support for this finding.  Their results showed that NFs (and INFs in particular) self-identified as Democrat (or Independent) much more so than Republican. To the extent that Democrats self-identify as politically liberal and Republicans self-identify as politically conservative, then the results in our study for the NFs makes some sense. Moreover, the results from Macdaid's1 study showing SJs were overrepresented amongst those who reported they were "extremely" or "very" conservative politically supports the less liberal orientations reported by the SJs in this study.

 

Our experience with the mental functions groups and organizational politics also provides some theoretical rationale for the results found in this poll. We have discussed this experience here, as well as here, but will summarize that discussion and apply it to liberal and conservative political orientations in this discussion. In particular, our experience with the mental functions groupings and organizational politics derives from our use of two exercises with various student and work groups. In both exercises the participants are first assigned to mental functions groups. Then they are asked to (1) "Draw something that represents your ideal organization" and then (2) "draw a situation at work that your consider to be political". Our conclusions from this experience is that "good" politics is whatever enacts the ideal organization of each mental functions group. "Bad" politics is that which frustrates the enactment of one's ideal organization, typologically defined. The ideal organization for each mental functions group thus represents various characteristics and values with which each group would like to associate. In this manner, the ideal organization represents a form of ideal management or government.

 

The general themes of the ideal organization drawings reflect key differences in assumptions about the nature of management (or government) that are key to the differences between political liberals and political conservative. These include:

  • Assumptions about human nature: Human imperfectibility (conservative) vs. human perfectibility (liberal).
  • The degree of trust in efficacy of government: More suspicious (conservative) vs. more trusting (liberal).
  • Orientations to governmental evolution: Prefer more traditional, proven institutions (conservative) vs. prefer more innovative organizations (liberal).
  • Assumptions about hierarchy: Hierarchy is the natural order wherein individualism is afforded liberty (conservative) vs. community is the source of the social contract which ensures equality (liberal).

 

This list is neither exhaustive (more here) nor are the various categories mutually exclusive. The list, however, does provide a start for exploring how the mental functions groups manifest their political orientations through their depiction of their ideal organizations, especially with respect to the ST and NF differences.

The ideal organization of the ST groups is one metaphorically summarized as "the machine". This form of organization or government emphasizes the STs preference for a traditional form of organization that has existed for millennia, from the hierarchy of the Catholic Church to that of Max Weber's conceptualization of bureaucracy as an ideal organizational type. This form of government assumes that employees/citizens not only are imperfectible (expressed somewhat as Theory X in managerial thinking and various doctrines of original sin in theology) but this assumption of imperfectibility is manifest in a respect for the law of variety wherein conservatives recognize people naturally differ in individual abilities (e.g., intelligence) that result in natural differences in classes, orders, material conditions, and thus inequality. That the STs are overrepresented in such career fields as law enforcement and the military correlates well with the managerial notion that mechanistic organization represents a command-and-control form of organization. Conservative bureaucracy's orientation to policies, procedures, rules, specialization of labor, centralization of authority and so on address the ST conservatives' organizational attempts to account for the imperfectibility of employees/citizens, provide for gradual organizational evolution through proven means, and provide for a more trusted centralization of authority via policies, procedures, and rules (as has been created through employment contracts in organizational arrangements and voting in the realm of public politics). Thus, within the ST machine we find the Sensing types' preferences for experience, tradition, and the here-and-now combined with the Thinking types' preferences for the impersonal and skeptical.

The ideal organization of the NF groups is one metaphorically summarized as an organization/government that allows for the full expression of the "human spirit". This form of organization or government emphasizes the NFs preferences involving possibilities (N) for people (F). The NFs thus value organizations that allow for creativity, imagination, and innovation along with an abiding respect, empathy, and concern for life in all its relationships. Their ideal organization is one based on the assumption that people are "perfectible" (at least in terms of human growth and development), are trustworthy (Theory Y in managerial thinking), and are best governed in a manner that allows for an ongoing dialogue that seeks consensus problem solving (equality) in the service of a community's betterment. The tendency of NFs to be overrepresented among such occupational groups as the clergy, conselling psychology, and the fine arts demonstrates the expression of NF energy in the realm of the human spirit. Power is expressed not through Weber's rationalized bureaucracy but, rather, though a social contract that emerges from the ongoing dialogue that takes place within a community of commitment and respect, and incarnates a postmodern version of Rousseau's general will of the people. Rather than the constitutional federalism of the conservative Republican's representative democracy, the NFs' ideal organization finds expression (via Fichte) in Mary Parker Follet's concept of democracy as "a great spiritual force evolving itself from men, utilizing each, completing his incompleteness by weaving together all in the many-membered community life which is the true Theophany." Thus, within the NF ideal organization we find the Intuition types' preferences for creativity and innovation combined with the Feeling types' preferences for the nurturing the whole.

 

The results from the analyses of the effects of the mental functions groupings on political orientations showed the NFs scored more liberal than the STs on 4 of the 5 measures of political orientations (Social Attitudes was the exception). In some of these analyses, however, the NFs scored as significantly more liberal than the SF and NT groups (as well as the ST group) while these groups (SF and NT) did not differ significantly from the ST groups. Based on our experience with the ideal organization exercise, we speculate that the SF and NT groupings produce ideal organizations that, while somewhat more egalitarian (or "decentralized") than the ST ideal organization, the NF orientation to egalitarianism is much more pronounced than that of the other groupings (especially when the NF group is predominantly NFP).



For example, the ideal organization for the SF groups is one metaphorically summarized as "small family" or "team". Within this organization there clearly is an emphasis on equality of the team members and respect for the uniqueness of each team member. Invariably, however, the SF groups recognize an overarching goal or authority that governs the group (and thus implies some degree of hierarchy). A couple of examples might help. In one situation, the SF group drew a key holder much as one might find in one's kitchen. The structure holding all the keys can be seen as the hierarchically organizing principle of the group. Each group member, however, drew his or her own unique key with his or her name on the key--representing the uniqueness of each member. In another situation, the SF group drew an arrow. In this case, the single head of the arrow represented the group's unity of purpose and direction. However, each member of the group also drew in their own unique portion of the tail feathers that would guide the arrow--again representing the uniqueness of each member.

 

We think these metaphorical portraits reflect validly some of the liberal and conservative differences between the mental functions groups. As with any use of metaphor, however, some aspects of a phenomenon are emphasized while others are de-emphasized.  For example, we believe the ST characterization presented above clearly emphasizes many aspects of conservatism.  On the other hand, characterizing  conservatism as mechanistic in the sense of the ST ideal organization produces something of a conundrum in that the mechanistic form of industrial organization was something that early conservatives seem to have regarded with disdain.  As discussed in Kirk's book The Conservative Mind , early conservatives viewed the rise of the industrial organization as emblematic of a growing secularism and a decline of a traditional, more agrarian and religious society. To the extent that various writers of the Romantic movement were involved in this conservative critique of industrialization (as Kirk notes), then we have the interesting hypothesis of the NF conservative, in that the Romantic movement emphasized intuition and "feeling" (N and F) over the evolving empiricism and rationality (S and T).  Such relationships deserve further investigation, as well as remind us that politics indeed may make strange bedfellows, even typologically. 

 

 

Cluster Analysis. We also performed a cluster analysis using participant responses to the October 08 poll. Cluster analysis is a statistical technique that seeks to form homogeneous clusters that differ from other clusters. Cluster analysis sometimes is refered to as "typological analysis" and thus seems quite appropriate for deriving various clusters of "political types" from our data. We performed two cluster analyses. The first extracted three clusters and the second extracted four clusters.

Unlike the above analyses (dichotomies and type groupings), the cluster analyses included participants' self identification as Republican, Democrat, or Independent. Thus, the variables included in the cluster analyses included type preferences, party identification, sex, age, and the five political orientation measures. In both the 3-cluster and 4-cluster analyses, we explored the role of type as dichotomies only (E-I, S-N, T-F, and J-P) and as mental functions groupings (ST, SF, NF, and NT) with the E-I and J-P dichotomies also included.

Results from the analyses produced both common themes and a some interesting differences. One consistent theme involved participants who identified with the Republican Party. This cluster invariably included more than 98% of the Republican participants, significantly more males than females, and the smallest proportion of F and NF types. The cluster also included a moderate proportion of T and ST type participants (with the NT types modestly represented in one analysis). As might be expected, this cluster reported conservative scores on the political orientation measures with economic conservatism being stronger than social conservatism. The proportion of Independents in this cluster ranged from about 27% to 44% depending upon the analyses. Fewer than 2% of Democrats fell into this cluster in each of the analyses.

A second theme was the tendency of the remaining clusters to be defined largely by Democrats followed by Independents. Further, the remaining clusters reported strong liberal orientations with social orientations generally more significant than economic orientations. The remaining clusters, however, differed in terms of the influence of the following variables: E-I, T-F, J-P, mental functions, and sex.

In the analyses where type preferences were included as the four separate dichotomies, two of the remaining clusters were distinguished by E or I preferences. The E cluster contained a large proportion of E participants along with a moderate proportion of participants who identified as Democrat or Independent. The E cluster also contained a moderate representation of F types (and the fewest T types) or a larger proportion of females than males (depending upon the analysis). The I cluster contained a large proportion of of the I participants and a moderate proportion of Democrats and Independents. In the four-cluster solution, the I cluster also contained a moderate proportion of females (and few males). A fourth cluster was not defined by the E-I dichotomy; rather this extra cluster contained about 1/3 of the male participants and about 1/4 of the F types (with only 1% of the T types). Party membership was not a significant influence on this group. And, in contrast to the other non-Repubican clusters, this cluster tended to express stronger economic liberalism.

In the analyses where type preferences were included as mental functions (along with E-I and J-P dichotomies), the remaining clusters largely were defined by sex and the J-P preferences, along with the mental functions grouping. The three-custer solution produced one cluster defined by a large proportion (80%) of female participants (with 0% males) and a large proportion (62%) of the NF participants. A majority (64%) of Democrat participants also were in this cluster along with about 37% of Independents. The second cluster was a male cluster (61% of male participants and 0% female) along with about 34% of the Democrat participants and 18% Independents. In the four-cluster solution, the female-Democrat-NF group split off another cluster, distinguished largely by the J-P preferences. The female-Democrat-NF cluster became a female-Democrat-NF-P group (with slightly smaller proportions of Democrat and NF participants--but with no J participants). The new cluster was a female-Democrat-J cluster. The cluster contained no males, no P types, and no Republican participants.

The foregoing discussion of the results from the cluster analyses raise at least three questions for further discussion:

  • Why did only one "Republican" cluster emerge whereas two or three "Democrat/Independent" clusters emerged?
  • Why did the E-I and J-P preference dichotomies influence the cluster formations when no significant effect was found for these preferences in the other analyses?
  • Why did participant sex influence the formation of so many clusters?


As an answer to the first question we must quote Will Rogers: "I belong to no organized political party -- I am a Democrat". This quote reflects an ongoing stereotype about Democrats, and thus Republicans, in that Republicans generally have been seen--at least over the past decade or so--as the talking-points-memo party. This characterization suggests Republicans are more unified and organized in contrast to Rogers' sarcasm suggesting that Democrats are not so organized. The correlations between participants who identify with the Republican party and their type preferences as E, S, T, and J also suggests that Republicans may have a more unified and organized political self-identity than do Democrats. Political dynamics over the past few years leading up to the 2008 U.S. presidential election would, however, seem to discredit this perspective somewhat. In particular, the Republican party clearly has become more divided as latent schisms between social conservatives, economic conservatives, neo-conservatives, and so on have become more apparent as a result of the 2008 election process. Rather, another answer to this question may come from the limitations in the distribution of the sample data. That is, given the relatively smaller proportion of participants in the poll who identified as Republican, the sample size may not be large enough to provide an opportunity for differences in this cluster to emerge (and form other Republican clusters).

Given these limitations, however, the results for the "Republican" cluster accord with the perspective of Republicans as more likely to be conservative politically and male than are Democrats. That T types and ST types are more frequently represented in the Republican cluster while F and NF types are only marginally represented seems reasonable given the liberal-conservative orientations for these types discussed above.

Our second question involves the E-I and J-P preferences. These preferences showed no significant relationships in the analyses focusing solely on the relationships between type and political orientations. Yet, these preferences played a significant role in the formation of some clusters. Why the different effects? One key to answering this question is to keep in mind that the cluster analyses included party identification whereas the other analyses did not. Further, research using the FFM suggests that personality and party identification are related such that Es and Js are likely to identify with more conservative or rightist political parties whereas Is and Ps are more likely to identify with more liberal or leftist parties. Unfortunately, these FFM results do not seem to apply in our situation given that the E-I and J-P effects are influential only in discriminating non-Republican clusters. Further, the influence is to discriminate clusters which generally contain females, Democrats, F types, and NF types. Like other results in this study, these results may be due to the distribution of the participants in the study. However, the results from the 1998 Consulting Psychologists Press study do provide an interesting perspective. In that study, INFs were the least likely of all the 16 types to self-identify as Republican and the INFJs were the most likely of all the whole types to self-identify with Democrats. ENFs did not show as clear a discrimination between party leanings with both the ENFPs and the ENFJs self-identifying almost uniformly across all three party identifications: Republican, Democrat, and Independent. When combined with the results from the cluster analyses, the implication is that (at least in the NF case) the E preference is associated with identification with a variety of parties whereas the I preference is associated with a disinclination to identify as Republican. Further, the P preference is associated with a greater willingness to identify as Independent whereas the J preference is negatively associated with Independence.

Our final question is: why did participant sex influence the formation of so many clusters?  As discussed above, the distribution of males and females varied significantly across some clusters. In particular, the Republican cluster consistently contained a larger proportion of male participants than female  participants.  In the mental functions analyses there was a clear tendency for a male-Democrat cluster to emerge separate from a largely female-Democrat-NF cluster.  Further, the J-P influence was evident only in female clusters, with 0% males in these two clusters.  One possible answer to this question, again, is that the results are indigenous to the participant pool.  Another more theoretical speculation is provided by those authors and commentators who have stereotyped the political parties in terms of the sexes.  For example, political commentator Chris Matthews has referred to the Republican Party as the "Daddy" party and the Democratic party as the "Mommy" party.  Similarly, University of California, Berkeley linguistics professor George Lakoff has referred to liberal and conservative political orientations in terms of family dynamics where liberals are framed in terms of  the "Nurturing Parent" metaphor  and conservatives are framed in terms of the "Strict Father" metaphor.


These speculations reflect an ongoing debate in the social sciences as well as the psychological type community about the "gendering" of various social and psychological constructs.  For example,  the effect of sex-role stereotyping in the realm of occupations has long been studied . Moreover, the type community has long focused on sex differences in responses to the T-F index (and the fact that 76% of females scored as F in the norming of the Form M appears to do little to assuage these concerns). Research on the role of sex in terms of party membership, attitudes toward various political issues, and voting behavior, however, suggest that there are differences along these lines both within parties by sex as well as between parties by sex.  Thus, a study with more conservative and Republican participants is needed along with studies that discriminate between sex (male and female) and gender (masculinity and femininity) as they relate to type and political orientations. The general regression results reported above further support this need for research in that males and T types, more so than females and F types, reported more conservative political orientations.

 

 

Theory-Method Considerations

 

As we have noted in various parts of our discussion, there has been an ongoing debate in the type community about  what constitutes a psychological type and how best to statistically analyze type data.  On the one hand, there are those2 who have argued for something of a "subgroup" approach where each whole type is taken as the unit of analysis (especially when using correlations as a foundation for analysis). When applied to this study, such an approach would seem to require, e.g., that our factor analysis of the political orientations measures be conducted on each of the 16 types separately, with subsequent analyses similarly constrained. To employ such an analysis would require a sample size of at least 10 responses for each of our 20 political orientation items for each of the 16 types, or 10x20x16=3600 participants. Clearly, our sample did not allow for such an examination.

 

On the other hand, there are those3 who have argued that the whole-type perspective--along with the associated notion of type dynamics--has not met the test of empirical examination.  Rather, the suggestion amongst these researchers is that type effects are most likely to occur at the level of the individual types alone or in additive combinations.  Our analyses, to some extent, have been able to test this view and the results here generally are supportive of this viewpoint.  For example, our regression analysis indicated that main effects--especially for the S-N and T-F preferences--were related to our political orientation measures in theoretically meaningful ways. Further, our tests for relationships between interactions of type variables and political orientation measures met with no success.  On the other hand, our analyses of the subgroups suggested the type preferences do combine to produce effects on political orientations.  

 

Within the context of these two consideration, we thus offer the results here as a limited examination of the relationship between psychological type preferences and political orientations.  And, hopefully the results provide suggestions for future research.  We cannot say, however, that the results provide any rigorous insight into the ongoing debate discussed above.

 

------------

1Macdaid, G. P. (1999, February). Facts from the CAPT databank. Paper presented at the Second Biennial Clinical Conference  of the Center for the Applications of Psychological Type, Gainesville, FL.

 

2Mitchell, W. D. (2000).  Cautions regarding aggregated data analysis in type research.  Journal of Psychological Type, 53, 19-30.

 

3Reynierse, J. H. (2009, January). The case against type dynamics. Journal of Psychological Type, 69(1), 1-21.

 



 




2005-2012 Politicaltypes.com
Joomla Template by Joomlashack
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack Joomla Templates
purchase abilify 20mg canada tindamax medication on line is generic zestril effective buy canada no prescription for relafen lexapro celexa anxiety online capoten india buy buspar with e check costco online delivery australia best site to buy diltiazem how to buy tulasi in london i pill zenegra website colchicine discount card can you buy toradol in ireland snovitra super power online store discount depakine chrono otc discount delta cortef otc where can i buy levothyroxine tablets l thyroxine without a prescription celexa over the counter uk astelin online no prescription comprar tricor original generic imitrex buy canada buy flovent online without prescription propranolol overdose antidote normal dosage of zoloft is it illegal to order generic calan renagel pct buy uk pharmacies online that sell metronidazole cost of mail clincin glycomet tablets on line to buy acticin with paypal payment lexapro 20 mg cost buy vardenafilum online reviews buy tretinoin 0,05 with paypal rumalaya for sale buy alavert using paypal discount procardia xl buy voveran online from usa where can i order deltasone hydrochlorothiazide generic manufacturers order frusemide from canada without prescription clomifene prescription only prandin order buy alphagan with discount olmesartan medoxomil tablets where can i get zestril from tadacip 40 mg dose where to buy acivir online canada can you order duetact can i order tofranil online furosemide shop net telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide bioequivalence prescription cheap price order estrace without genuine silagra best price feldene without script promethazine 10 mg cost cheap rx7 exhaust buy valtrex online cheap no prescription beta val delivered to your home methotrexate sublingual dosage reglan to buy from europe zyprexa dose for schizophrenia cheap genuine zovirax online himplasia reviews resources for desyrel metformin weight gain antipsychotic healthy bmi for 25 year old male buy advair tablets australia best price for real altace female cialis mg india buy botanical slimming tablets kamagra oral jelly with american express when is generic zyprexa available diclofenac online bestellen safe paroxetine no precription trial erection packs 2 drug in fr pharmacy buy trial erection packs 1 greece does allegra d come in generic form flagyl for men sale in uk clarinex sales 2010 diclofenac gel fast usa bystolic over the counter keflex for uti duration disulfiramo brands india pharmacies canada vpxl thyrox cheap us pharmacy cheap generic allegra buy rogaine 5 online from uk can pletal and plavix be taken together buy hyzaar 5 grifulvin v suppliers overseas nizoral order online can you get valaciclovir canadian pharmacy board exam order ginseng online with visa diprosone cheap canada pharmacy generic acnetane no prescription nitroglycerin without insurance provera prix en pharmacie en france where to get ovral l pct what is reglan for dogs discount medications dogs zyprexa overdose long term effects bupron noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy best place to buy voveran sr in mexico can you only get glucotrol xl on prescription order roxithromycin uk pharmacy valtrex canada drug store cheap actos per pill pioglitazone olanzapine tablets uses buyers of amitriptyline canada albenza next day ciprofloxacina side effects uk diovan price in pakistan buy burspirone without a prescription misoprostol abortion pill health canada didronel canadian drug company zyban amantadine buy australia generic cialis no prescription uk buy septilin mg otc bacterial shampoo buy sarafem without a prescription from canadian pharmacy where do i buy cialis sublingual flovent medication class can you buy fucidin in ireland buy generic nolvadex online with prescription revia pricing order generic trandate buy cheap diarex low price pletal uk buy atomoxetin online no prescription where to buy augmentin online uk slimming tablets with speed in very cheap shatavari xenical reviews side effects where avapro silagra over the counter drugs online generic plavix buy alphagan cheap how long does it take for propecia side effects to stop aprovel for men in usa price increase avodart hydrochlorothiazide woldwide shipping diprolene discount no prescription aspirin tablets purchase on line sinequan us companies only list banned drugs india buy minomycin cheap bactrim wanted online review vytorin 10 10 price american malegra dxt ondansetrona generico italiano diflucan birth control online uk ranbaxy lipitor recall lot numbers disulphiram order canada what is famvir used for diflucan in croatia best place to buy provera in uk risperdal generic name trial erection packs 1 drug schedule mexico pharmacies online that sell topamax where to buy viagra super active with mastercard arzomicin without prescrip onde comprar exelon patch comprar hydrea portugal cheap abilify 1 pharmacy guaranteed sertraline hcl side effects men no prescription diarex buy clomid tablets us pill rx health retin a gel 0,1 products why is there a shortage of revia is lexapro legal in uk celadrin pills online in the usa buying aldactone in manchester buy sumycin from mexico online low altace side effects ramipril long term side effects of medrol dosepak buy retino a cream 0 05 mg online nizagara pharmacy prices list what is cialis super active drugs prescription solutions by optumrx member login buy antivert overseas cheap genuine tinidazole online is generic otomax effective generic pilex pravachol phone orders cheapviagrausa.com buy malegra dxt hong kong skelaxin generic 2013 drugs asacol canada companies only zyprexa 50mg tablets terramycin looking for order aloprim online no prescription with a visa where to buy prednisona online usa discount himplasia motrin 800 mg high serophene to buy in the usa without a prescription ordering reglan usa is lopid a prescription drug ordering zoloft online no prescription buy genuine ginseng uk buy l thyroxine with paypal metformin phone orders best online pharmacy india cheapest cyklokapron in the uk genuine sumycin 100mg annual sales of lipitor 2010 can you buy ventolin over counter france methylprednisolone tablets usp 4 mg dosage safe to buy generic fluticanose from usa amaryl glimepiride wikipedia propranolol buy online india prednisolona to buy in the usa without a prescription cheap doxazosin 2 mg arzomicin in usa nymphomax generic cheap costs propranolol 40mg ampicillin manufacturer in india buying cialis super active in manchester the morning after pill free nymphomax mg buy can you order lansoprazol buspar 10mg street price flagyl er pills sweat disulphiram no rx etabus next day delivery how to get vantin in australia buy cyproheptadine periactin amoxiline tablets online is ortho cyclen available on line in canada western drug nexium viagra plus direct pharmacy bactroban maximum dosage bupron online india generic caffeine ergotamine in usa long term side effects of nexium use toprol xl 100mg generic erythromycin suspension discontinued brand name prazosin online paroxetine australia price erythromycin medication where to buy purchase accutane 10mg opening cymbalta capsules zocor without script doxycycline with american express current price evista vpxl mg india will there generic aricept current price metformin albenda discount no prescription sarafem online pay paypal tretinoin 0 025 buy canada suppliers of amoxycillin in us cephalexin in croatia diarex with no perscription cheap pills bentyl mg zyprexa best price zithromax class of medication tadacip now keflex dose pediatrica side effects of zyvox 600 mg janumet prices at costco amantadina de 100 mg where is aspirin absorbed in the body valacyclovir overseas online pharmacy buy generic torsemide online with prescription where to buy actoplus online uk cipla pharma careers what is trental lopressor iv onset tretinoin spain where to buy frusemide mg shortage of voltaren gel lexapro in india no prescription erection packs 2 what does phenergan generic allergic can i take 2 unisom sleeptabs viagra sildenafil citrate 50mg tizanidina uk pharmacy the online drugstore brafix ordering hytrin brand cialis cheap us pharmacy erection packs 2 over the counter do you need rx fluconazol abilify mg canada prescription mobic is for genuine vytorin best price maxalt to buy in australia lioresal generic for where can i purchase apo clopidogrel lithium canada no prescription what is topamax prescribed for where can i buy chewable zyrtec purchase clopidogrelum online no prescription proventil delivered to your home what is furosemide for dogs allegra to buy in australia cialis cheapest lowest price allegra printing orlando florida what does a dramamine high feel like generic drug for lanoxin finpecia capsules what is the medication decadron used for order ephedraxin uk pharmacy can you get dulcolax over the counter donde comprar maxalt lasix no prrescription low price estradiol valerate uk flomax prices at costco keflex online purchase cheap cefixime india is coreg a prescription drug strattera prescription online name brand minomycin online vardenafilum no prescription fedex ups what is the shelf life for prednisone tablets generic name for levitra professional predalone dose erythromycin dosage australia cheap calan bosch villas approved innopran xl drug in uk pharmacy donde conseguir cialis discount metformina canada pharmacy celebrex medicine online buy buspar cats buy aygestin online amazon buy zebeta inhaler canada ciprofloxacina shopping liposafe uk no prescription ortho cyclen without a prescription from canada olistat online in uk albenza pinworm dose to buy ovral l generic lisinopril no prescription average cost of abilify zentel over counter tinidazole online coupon code skelaxin 800 mg coupons canadian medicines ltd review can you take feldene daily trandate birth control online us abilify prices walgreens order liv 52 without prescription viagra soft online australia is mail order albuterol safe canada and micronase renagel medication online wellbutrin dose rxlist fluoxetina for sale philippines trazodone generic 2013 drugs citalopram sold over counter how to get prescription drugs with no prescription what is lisinopril for how to take misoprost mg ou peut on acheter du baclofene over the counter antibiotic eye drops uk viagra sublingual pharmacy mail order can you buy yaz in ireland himcolin comprare purchase geriforte on line in uk what is the generic name for diovan ventolin salbutamol syrup buy viagra super active online usa orlistar canada drug store clozaril generico online vytorin on line in the uk buy actoplus met canada compazine delivery uk atacand no script celebrex lawsuit 2010 how to purchase actos pyridium buy canada where purchase ciprofloxacina nexium 40 mg pret compensat quickest female cialis online drug shop danazol capsules uses tamsulozin usa no prescription baridium roche precio argentina generic pills for betoptic what does differin viagra cheap india how to order keftab brand name cialis online canada oder mg tablets of capoten research chemicals usa buy buying nolvadex purchase januvia on line in australia buy generic zofran online no prescription low price retin a 0 025 uk co enalapril 20 mg how long does it take for meclizine to wear off generic risperdal uk paypal negative side effects of singulair in children ordering periactin on line antabuse implant usa brand cialis online purchase cilest from mexico buy nitrofurantoin online cheap discount leukeran mg billig v gel online kaufen where can i buy innopran xl motilium tablets 150 mg no prescription cheap price order lipitor no rx etodolac online buy canadian chloramphenicol doxycycline hyclate generic drug is cialis covered by insurance omnicef birth control online uk coreg over counter uk zofran injection spc retin a gel 0 1 cost canadian is lamisil over the counter order lipitor without rx caverta medicine best site to buy tizanidina where to get propecia in australia actos without prescription miami pill rx health tadacip products mircette from australia resources for mobic quickest cedax buy suprax where to buy erection packs 3 online without rx discount code for proventil lov cost cystone aleve 100 tablets ordering beconase aq uk emoquette lawsuit canada isoptin dosage recommended cardizem coupons tricor cheap canada pharmacy renova side effects long term use wellbutrin without script parlodel brands india best site get simvastatina is it illegal to order generic retin a 0,05 doxycycline pharmacy coupons uk pharmacies online that sell probalan best levitra price antivert over the counter india where to buy accutane with amex purchase carvedilolo on line in the uk kamagra gold lawsuit canada generic isotretin usa pharmacy can you buy minomycin in ireland buy zetia fast shipping where do i buy effexor xr yasmin pill price philippines buy minocin tablets australia buy flucazole online from india allegra usa cvs prices buy cipro online in the united states without a prescription india acivir pills price zebeta canada online no prescription epivir hbv for daily use canada vardenafilum drug schedule urispas online usa no prescription list of ayurvedic pharmacies in india how to pay by check irs order zyloprim tablets etabus over the counter drugs cheap elavil amitriptyline buy compazine tablets online purchasing calan online cialis discount pharmacy allopurinol discount anti acidity blood generic lamictal problems bipolar pharmacy has best price olanzapine how to take clomid tablet rogaine 2 drug class purchase zentel on line in usa brand name baclofen online generic salbutamol switzerland overnight nolvadex accepted revatio no prescription overnight delivery best online pharmacy generic rumalaya liniment causes of chlamydia in men where could i buy zebeta without prescription combivent delivery view next topic mail order generic lithium viagra sublingual mail order generic for celebrex 200 mg can you buy eulexin in ireland diamox non perscription countries tetracycline shortage bc post steroid cycle therapy clomid antabuse dose range can cozaar pills be cut in half erythromycin stearate tablets 500mg spc neurontin online mexico non prescription speman pharmacy canadian benadryl tablet ditropan xl cost buy voltaren next day online pharmacy uk curacne buy caverta new zealand online 24h pharmacy ordering ondansetrona india what is the maximum dosage for effexor xr is it safe to order glucofage xenical drug schedule aspirin in pregnancy nice guidance purchase duprost online purchase generic alfa flucon minomycin from mexico buy alavert without a subscription online pharmacy dutasterid where do i cilest in mexico percocet for sale australia cheap aciclovir 1 200mg 400mg baclofen side effects memory glucophage now cheap promethazine codeine atacand blood pressure pills 100 mg silagra suprax 200 mg dosage cheap liverpool hotels deals how much is sominex tablets cheapest medrol dosepak tablets uk buy amlodipinbesilat in ireland order medication online kaiser buy promethazine codeine syrup no prescription viagra with bonus pills can you buy chloramphenicol eye drops nizagara generico online fluoxetine to buy from europe generic lioresal for sale on line florida lipothin glucovance legal us finpecia tablets on line to buy is lansoprazol available on line in canada order synthroid rx calan uk brand name prinivil over counter celebrex daily use reviews vermox from canada buytamoxifen citrate from new zeland disulfiramum uk next day delivery cymbalta pills cost augmentin from usa pharmacy zyvox coupon online generic sertralina buy canada where can i purchase mentat buy forzest paypal accepted canada cipralex tablets online maxaman online from canada american bisoprololi fumaras minipress mg india plendil shipping overseas is generic cardura available in usa glucovance india no prescription what is rumalaya liniment used for percocet in usa synthroid reviews retino a cream 0,05 medicine online gasex no prescription abilify buy online uk is there an over the counter medicine like flonase zovirax online shop cipro medicine for sinus infection buy vasotec 20 mg original alti doxycycline online purchase emsam shuddha guggulu suppliers overseas better than tadalis cipla pharmaceuticals mumbai ciprofloxacin eye drops for ear genuine exelon best price acivir pills without a prescription seroflo italiano cozaar where to buy in canada pill rx health midamor products viagra professional where to buy in canada ceftin on line purchase diamox 20 mg buy nolvadex online australia puerto rico rincon inn what is levaquin generic name what is procardia for retino a cream 0 05 for sale uk buy arjuna pills in the australia buy amlodipinbesilat online no prescription pravachol from usa cialis singapore clinic max dose of topamax for migraines my alli diet supplement side effects of norvasc drug best place to buy albendazole in uk precio del viagra en el salvador voltaren gel maximum dose is it safe to order carvedilolo buy colchicine mexican pharmacies artane new zealand baclofen pas cher italie us online pharmacy no prescription avandamet albendazole medication order what is the correct dosage of mircette bentyl tablets 10 mg where to buy proscar drugs online order skelaxin online canada buy aricept online uk allegra 60 mg over the counter clomid dosage pct forum lithium canadian medications without prescription digoxin class action lawsuit finasteride medication guide malegra fxt online ordering cheap topamax purchase combivent in india metoclopramide on the internet best sex pill over counter buy kamagra soft boots albenza pills online in the mexico buy levitra super active no prescription best place to order dipyridamole in us what does protonix look like get prescription online doctor uk neurontin delivered to your home procardia pills online in the uk compare prices himcolin buy albendazole with no rx buy hytrin tablets india buy geriforte syrup online from usa order trial erection packs 1 online no prescription with a mastercard eulexin without rx phone in order for brand levitra what is etodolac 400 mg tablet used for prednisone tablets 10 mg picture canadian online pharmacy cialis prilosec 10mg packet side effects of long term use of imuran low cost order periactin generic buspar reviews 2012 purchase dutas on line in uk erection packs 2 cost in canada flonase to buy from europe cialis 40 mg dosage western drug orlistatum triderm crema pret zoloft dose too high what are the side effects of taking accutane can you order rhinocort discount best place to buy ponstel in usa erection packs 1 birth control online canada lowest priced zenegra cefixime community acquired infection what types of amoxil are there protonix cost in canada azithromycin online purchase max skelaxin dose xenical sale nz overnight pharmacy brand amoxil viagra generika kaufen bestellen ordering dilantin buy indocin over the counter drugs similar to pariet buying provera in manchester where can i get styplon generic renova in usa indian pharmacy fluticanose best buy live online support roxithromycin tablets 300mg biaxsig buy fluoxetina online india best place to buy cafergot in canada diprolene canadian online health canada diarex isoptin india sale probalan dose viagra spain prescription reviews of canadian online pharmacies cozaar generic yet sertralina roche precio argentina zovirax tablets dosage genital herpes generic raloxifeno uk paypal buy online clozaril generic suprax without a script voltaren emulgel canadian pharmacy codeine syrup boots xenical next day delivery online discount order grifulvin v what kind of blood pressure medicine is lisinopril what is the generic for effexor xr pariet worldwide who is online pharmacy usa website usa buy sominex without prescription ciprofloksacin online purchase what is the medication valtrex used for order dostinex online canada fluconazole and alcohol interaction lyrica versus neurontin weight gain generic diovan hct 160 25 viagra tablets side effects in urdu can you take l thyroxine daily buy dipyridamole perth australia without script allopurinol online cod is cipro a generic drug buy singulair 40 crestor coupons canada pill rx health evista products fincar birth control online india stieva a uk companies only fastest simvastatina uk delivery cheapest zerit generic lamictal manufacturer ophthacare perth australia cheapest roxithromycin tablets uk pyridium medication doctor lotrisone without a prescription where can i buy rogaine 2 tablets levaquin canada pharmacy coumadin ordering online pharmacy nolvadex pharmacy order order olanzapine from uk without prescription safe to buy generic prednisone from usa medicine calander patient femcare pharmacy is it safe to order depakote bactrim online order sarafem no prescription compare prices snovitra super power medication overnight delivery skelaxin shipping overseas female viagra over the counter buy online lynoral generic amlodipine 5mg side effects nhs buy generic renagel online delivery cheap alphagan online buy sominex online from india buyers of renova canada where to buy viagra jelly online uk plavix express canada cheap calan us order approved buy amantadine hcl tricor online with out prescription lariam coupons where to buy yasmin pills depakote canadian pharmacy suhagra prescription coupon legal buy femara online canada azithromycin 250 buy nolvadex without prescription what is roxithromycin tablets used for all types propecia pills tegretol mg order generic uk paypal acai astelin non perscription countries best place to buy promethazine lisinopril hctz side effects erectile dysfunction aripiprazola on line in the mexico cheap keftab 100 mg buy disulphiram online no prescription us pharmacy that sells cordarone best place to order lipothin in us buy zestril online at canada pharmacy cialis viagra or levitra medications how to order liponexol online purchase albuterol on line in the uk amantadine no prescription fedex ups cheapest bupron paypal suprax 100 mg 5 ml cost of mail diclofenac cheap canadian quetiapinum no prescription cheap risperdal 3mg 100 mg tricor what are the side effects of diovan 40mg erythromycin cz kytril delivery london dapoxetine mg usa side effects of cholesterol medication crestor mometasona online india how to buy finasteride what are the side effects of norvasc medication order percocet online canada vasodilan online usa no prescription furosemide 20 mg for sale dostinex medication side effects prozac without a prescription from uk overnight pharmacy cyprus online sominex india cheap diclofenac suppository drug best place to buy bactroban in canada tadapox dosage too high diprosone ov cream side effects xeloda mail order pain meds that start with the letter d ciprofloxacino 500 mg tabletas synthroid 75 mcg dosage atrovent inhaler generic cardura drug in fr pharmacy v gel online coupon code discount viagra online soft tabs where do i promethazine in usa is emsam legal in uk actos drugstore com tindamax online in usa buy generic propecia 5mg online accredited pharmacy technician online program buy finpecia bulk 40 mg buspar buy quetiapinum boots pharmacy where to buy cytotec in canada safely best site get prednisolone where do i buy neurontin where to buy minocin drugs online how to purchase trial erection packs 3 online buying emsam in manchester aviane 28 online pay paypal erection packs 1 phone orders sildenafila to purchase without a prescription sarafem 10 mg tablet avalide canadian online zertalin without insurance lisinopril and hydrochlorothiazide tablets usp cialis jelly cheap uk ortho tri cyclen pills different colors cefadroxil fast mexico use tamoxifen bodybuilding danazol mexico no prescription demadex daily use reviews buy anafranil 80 mg online what is premarin prescribed for arimidex dosage instructions penicillin pills for sale propranolol 80 mg capsules picture where to buy glucovance with echeck can i buy chloramphenicol eye drops over the counter cheapest micardis tablets uk soviclor side effects compazine online coupon code methotrexate generic price generic zyban cost kamagra oral jelly for sale uk cheap calan forcat holidays menorca is it safe to order novo digoxin buy kamagra without a subscription where can i purchase coumadin ordering compazine diarex trusted online drug stores in canada fluoxetina on line in the usa cost of procardia without insurance what is injuv hyaluronic acid for where can i buy diclofenac gel in canada what is purinethol 50 mg tizanidina no rx canadian healthcare system issues where to buy atacand in canada safely buy proscar with no rx is viagra a controlled substance in florida avapro no prescription needed ephedraxin pills buy online cialis 30 day free offer zestoretic canada drug store generic himplasia for sale on line metformin for discount lamictal bouton visage how to import flonase cephalexin 500mg australia us pharmacies online that sell thyroxine canada drugs dapoxetine with prescription generic clomifene switzerland the online drugstore levlen fasigyn order antabuse side effects impotence minocin 100mg reviews zovirax cheap india pharmacy ciplox free shipping legal online asacol feldene for dogs buy american avodart snafi tadalafil adalat cc rxlist can order xalatan online allegra otc usa levlen cheap mexico pharmacy buy anafranil in uk midamor on line purchase low cost arava glucophage usa combivent dosage for copd estrace in the uk anyone take atarax for anxiety purchase levitra in us buy actos pioglitazone canada generic cost of hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg albendazole online pay paypal viagra super active us companies only canada and brand levitra how to use extendaquin dostinex legal us best place buy zyvox pct buy voveran sr online no prescription uk generic coumadin switzerland pills buy albendazole online pra que serve o remedio cloridrato de sertralina levothyroxin from mexico trazodone for insomnia user reviews aygestin no prescription overnight delivery anafranil direct pharmacy drugstore coupon code 5 off fluoxetina order canada buy generic remeron online precio de pastillas cytotec en venezuela meclizine overnight pharmacy canadian drugs buy glucotrol xl ordering ortho cyclen india purchase xenical mg no prescription lithium sale order vasodilan without prescription order inderal online no prescription with a amex generic cozaar usa buy adderall online adderall weight loss average beat way to order motilium kelnor uk buy can you buy cipralex over the counter aldactone 100 mg pcos buy aleve capsules content management system wiki ondansetrona over the counter uk canadian vicoprofen what is the medicine actos used for where to buy yaz without a prescription fluticanose cost in canada get dilantin toronto buy online wellbutrin sr generic over the counter drugs similar to seasonique buy oestrogel online with out prescription side effects of ramipril tablets is sildenafil citrate from india safe cheap dostinex mg to buy retino a cream usa buy eurax without prescription comprar viagra en argentina online femcare without prescription generic doxazosin cost buy ortho tri cyclen cheap buy isotretin greece generic allopurinol 300mg prescription tretinoin fast mexico buy glucotrol without prescription moduretic online overnight shipping oristal over counter provera cheap uk omnicef mg order cost of levothyroid order maxalt testosterone cream reviews women long term side effects of lotrel atarax hydroxyzine hcl 10mg antipsychotic drugs risperdal buy acai online from mexico buy actos pills in the australia ordering brafix on line toprol dose cafergot tablets dosage ponstel supplier in uk getting olanzapine in australia no prescription albendazole isotretin where can i buy it cheap feldene pills zyloprim buy australia how to take finax legal buy esperal online canada metformin usan where to buy arjuna lanoxin precio mexico what is the medication cipro used for is generic oxytrol effective methotrexate by mail canada lamictal tablets online omnicef pharmacy mail order cialis sales predictions tadapox online usa no prescription ciplox without rx safe to buy generic avalide from usa iui with clomid success rates amlodipin online pharmacy shipped to canada getting minipress in australia paroxetine tablets us online american ginseng benefits tcm what is the typical seroquel dosage for bipolar no prescription paypal type antibiotic doxycycline hyclate abilify prescriptions online antipsychotic is motrin better than tylenol for fever order vytorin from moduretic birth control online uk order cozaar uk pharmacy citalopram hbr 40 mg tablets xalatan limited india alli and thyroid medications buy ceftin without rx apo clopidogrel side effects long term use safe midamor no precription what drug category is novo digoxin buy apo furosemida online us no prescription avodart prescription prices buy betoptic without rx buying erection packs 1 are all yasmin pills the same cialis free sample malegra dxt online purchase what is the generic for lopid order avapro pills parlodel india pharmacy venta de pastillas alli en mexico purchase aciphex 200 mg health canada betapace buy meclizine online from uk serpina birth control online australia sumycin without a prescription from india list of tesco stores selling antara drug sales 2011 levitra walmart price can you get prescription without seeing doctor detrol mg canada propecia finasteride same thing where can i get lotensin metronidazole gel buy online no prescription viagra professional pills buy online canada buy mobic without prescription where to buy amoxycillin online usa naprosyn from china without script buy astelin how to use terramycin ointment serophene drug in uk pharmacy allegra for sale cost of cymbalta costco russian pharmacy 1010 hyzaar drugstore com pricing rocaltrol tablets uses how to take lipitor generic pilex overnite shipping where to buy amaryl with mastercard where to buy nitrofurantoin with echeck pharmacy has best price evista depo medrol generico how clomiphene works as a fertility drug lipitor store drugs canadian buy diprolene online overnight delivery diovan cheaper alternative roxithromycin uses medication best place to buy levaquin in mexico generic ortho cyclen usa pharmacy propranolol australia price what is the maximum dose of methotrexate for rheumatoid arthritis order arzomicin no rx canadian pharmacy rythmol sr pills buy online orlistatum overnight delivery all types bentyl pills testosterone therapy for women libido buy torsemide mexican pharmacies order zestoretic from uk without prescription buy provera 10mg non prescription almetec where to buy levitra professional with mastercard order diflucan from india without prescription xenical order online no prescription metronidazol where can i buy buspar no prescription what is riperdal pills used for cialis eu acheter pas cher furosemide desyrel no prescription canada dostinex drugstore com pricing buy medrol dosepak online without a prescription viagra jelly rx can you order finast buy cheap lotrisone cream buy elimite online in usa advair online purchase where to buy retino a cream 0,025 online india how to take kamagra 100 prednisone dosage for poison ivy diovan comprar amantadine sulfate pk merz paxil on line in the canada metrogel without a perscription zovirax tablets buy uk buy doxycycline astrailia online drug for ginseng reviews on reglan is it safe to order atorlip 5 eldepryl 10 mg cost quanto costa il viagra generico in farmacia allegra online forum generic cialis buy viagra buy alesse online cheap femara discount medications buy glucovance perth australia flovent cfd tenormin order online lisinopril comments lantus from canada without rx can you buy wigraine tamsulozin without prescription pills buy lipitor bulk erythromycin stearate 250 mg bactroban pharmacy prices list erection packs 11 drugs online allegra generic name are there any over the counter antibiotics for uti oder mg tablets of rosuvastatin nitroglycerin dosage adults what does lamictal pill look like prescription drug calan ou acheter du nolvadex best pharmacy to order amitriptyline best place buy aciphex yasmin refills can get elimite over counter propecia lawsuit canada buy generic beconase aq coreg suppositories buy imuran order online dosage of diflucan for candida clozaril mg usa prednisona posologia caes finpecia shelf life generic vytorin india buying singulair online legal buy fluconazol online with no prescription interesting facts about canadian healthcare clomifene prix en pharmacie en france discount dutasterid from canada buy danazol xr without prescription best place buy dulcolax pct delivery phenergan without buying norvasc in manchester crestor buy on line sustiva delivery london biaxin prescription assistance elavil online coupon code buy shuddha guggulu pills in the canada female viagra india no prescription where can i buy carafate online without a prescription buy lamictal pills online diclofenac sodium dosage for adults order lipitor from mexico without prescription cipro pills for eye infection asthma inhaler online no prescription generic pills for estrace cheap generic viagrafree shipping viagra from canadian online pharmacies atenolol anxiety dosage which uk site to buy noroxin grifulvin v generic wikipedia drugs norvasc buy online uk prilosec dose bactrim us pharmacy western drug adalat azitromicina generic canada no prescription uk buy betnovate cream 100g what is ginseng root extract allegra nursing shoes sale prednisona results forum buy movalis online with out prescription buy nymphomax with paypal retin a gel 0,1 from usa se comprar xenical sin receta mexico tizanidina mg no prescription purchase no prescription inhaler online order retino a cream on line uk erection packs 2 price india valsartan hct 80 12.5 mg can you only get nootropil on prescription aprovel online usa best place to buy desyrel in india best place buy synthroid pct erexin v online legally allopurinol on line in the canada buy online amitriptyline generic where to buy cefixime with mastercard tesco pharmacy opening times york most reliable place to buy noroxin online where to buy erection packs 2 in canada safely oristal over the counter uk pilex spain where to buy sildenafil tablets generic viagra for daily use antabuse side effects depression depakote australia price toprol purchase ordering glucotrol xl discount image glipizide buy maxaman hong kong metformin low dose birth control over counter fucidin buy trileptal online in the united states without a prescription buy propranolol pills in the mexico viagra pago paypal best place to buy ondansetrona united pharmacies uk modafinil generic amoxil uk paypal sodium diclofenac 50 mg remeron drug in canada pharmacy low dose cialis and bph which uk site to buy levitra buy minocycline online from mexico order geriforte no rx canadian pharmacy no script probalan mg cost of flunil without insurance zerit online coupon code order nitroglycerin on line uk phexin canada head office azithromycin tablets what are they for nexium prescription treatment disease can you buy testosterone cream over the counter buy vpxl online no prescription us side effects of depo provera while pregnant betnovate canadian online overnight pharmacy cara makan pil perancang mercilon zebeta mg uk buy diovan online canada valtrex online mexico buy premarin fast shipping cafergot uk boots hyaluronic acid doctors online most reliable place to buy plavix online buy cialis super active online us no prescription minomycin mist canada dapoxetine dosage recommended janumet supplier in uk rosuvastatin dose response sildenafila online from canada buy obelit inhaler canada finax by mail 24 hours most common side effects of biaxin raloxifeno for purchase without a prescription universal online pharmacy uroxatral online order ondansetrona canada no prescription purchase thyroxine in uk erythromycin sale online buy doksazosin lek online no prescription uk ventolin overnight shipping cheap how long does pariet take to work how to purchase buspar pill rx health disulphiram products como comprar levitra pela internet ampicillin mexico companies only cheap salbutamol no prescription how to use cleocin ovules nitroglycerin brand positioning neurontin canadian pharmacy acheter celexa pas cher water pills side effects cramps cefadroxil for men sale in uk is it safe to order salbutamol pediatric reglan dose order lotrisone on line uk buy canada no prescription for mircette generic keftab us hydrea costco zestoretic pfizer blue pill with watson 387 how to purchase hoodia online how to buy dyazide imitrex canada online no prescription buy anastrozolo online with out prescription what is aspirin used for heart mail order wellbutrin clomid success stories 2009 what are phenergan tablets finasteride side effects forum buy ginette 35 from canada canada pharmacies online that sell stediril altace from canada safe place order famvir buy alli tablets weight loss pamelor without rx paxil online overnight lotrisone ointment dosage levitra 20 mg reviews alli usage how long does diltiazem stay in your system how much will antabuse cost generic alfa flucon in usa atacand prices usa buy calcium carbonate visa buy brand sepibest medrol uk brand name meri adalat south indian buy viagra super active xr without prescription is it illegal to sell viagra in the uk safe buy precose online viagra local pharmacy buy parlodel without prescription buy coreg tablets canada ventolin salbutamol dosage in children how to purchase almetec duprost order in the us low cost arjuna alli weight loss medication coupon reminyl online in us pharmacy usa online cialis prescription serpina from mexico purchase zithromax z pak can buy tinidazole online buy trimox online at canada pharmacy where purchase lioresal hong kong buy haldol online drugs imuran dose for lupus top 10 online zoloft sites revatio for dogs buy tofranil pills buy online buy furosemide online with no prescription no prescription levitra super active plus trileptal uk sale ashwagandha pharmacy long term side effects of compazine buy artane with no rx average cost of generic lexapro etabus from india how much does lexapro cost at walmart order hyzaar online no presctiption purchase abilify 4 pharmacy malegra dxt order online no prescription indocin tablets 40mg order dipyridamole without prescription is cefadroxil safe in pregnancy neurontin from china cipla zepose 10 avapro lawsuit canada clomid no prescription twins plavix price philippines finasteride 5mg buy online buying celexa online how long does celexa stay in your system buy leukeran online overnight delivery prozac from usa ditropan pills sweat qsymia cost express scripts doksazosin lek shelf life best site get azitromicina half price oristal prescription drug ciprofloxacin 500mg buy betoptic paypal mevacor medication on line acai medication cozaar overnight shipping mg sustiva sent to spain best healthy mango smoothie metformin tablets in india medicamento lipiblock orlistate disulphiram mg canada cost of arimidex in uk allegra shortage 2012 diprosone over counter uk indian generics online retin a 0,05 bupron order canada buy tetracycline tablets uk what is ampicillin 500mg buy seroquel online canada can you buy viagra plus in ireland female pill shop order bystolic on line india order evista generic orlistat 120mg boots buy aceon 10 mg dog heartworm medicine with no prescription buy acivir pills online from usa ortho cyclen generic form evista canadian online buy tretinoin tablets uk buy cheap adderall online uk where is the best place to buy valium online where do i tadacip in mexico zithromax generic erection packs 1 for sale uk where do i floxin in uk ampicilina on line no script brahmi canada overnight delivery difference kamagra levitra over the counter allegra substitute research grade pyridium lamictal rx assistance over counter cyklokapron generic female cialis usa olanzapine canadian online how much promethazine with codeine syrup to get high where to buy otomax mg long time side effects blopress buy accutane cheap online isotretinoin fenofibrate costco caverta usa sale how to order tricor where to midamor order lexapro from canada atomoxetin buy mexico free viagra for women hoodia medication overnight delivery where do i imitrex in india ephedraxin from usa tamsulosin dose children trimox low dose birth control aleve without a script recommended dose of zantac for babies amaryl without a prescription from canada ayurslim us companies only tretinoin 0 025 tablets indian viagra jellyfish online drug buy cialis sublingual from canada naprosyn shop net hydroxy pure hoodia reviews where to buy cheap generic terramycin can order retin a 0 025 canada buy levoxyl mg online for low cost overnight famvir what is decadron 4 mg used for minoxidil 12.5 buy order motrin online without rx zoloft generic costa rica percentage of twins 100mg clomid prescription pills that get you high aceon prescription fedex overnight free purchase actos generic pharmacy how to order liv 52 purchase ranitidine 75 mg best place buy flagyl er flomax otc questionnaire indocin overnight shipping cheap the online drugstore synthroid baclofen billig kaufen crestor legal us bactrim on line in the mexico buy glucophage 40 diclofenac over the counter usa order carbozyne on line india accutane 40 mg once a day what is lisinopril drugs buy asthma inhalers mexico cipro xl 1000 mg side effects buy roxithromycin pills in the australia coreg generic cost can i buy my cozaar online without a prescription generic pills for tizanidina buy generic cialis 10mg top 10 online etabus sites propranolol 60 mg price bonnispaz us pharmacy purchase tizanidinum in australia buy over the counter asthma inhalers purchase alli on line in uk safest long term anxiety medication can order brand advair diskus online diprosone birth control online canada albuterol inhaler safe during pregnancy levitera disulphiram delivery london worldwide pharmacy distribution anafranil on line in the mexico online pharmacy uk mentat ds syrup pink viagra for sale order viagra soft lowest price accutane and drugs buy cystone next day buy acticin tablets uk can you buy ciprofloxacin buy atorlip 5 fast shipping donde comprar levitra mexico where to get unprescribed clomid where can i purchase obelit usa buy albenza without prescription rank these acids from weakest to strongest brand name clomifene online mentat drug in usa pharmacy buy ivenox online from canada what does erection packs 3 cleocin gel pills drugstore effexor xr com signup glycomet for sale australia cephalexin dog rx buy evecare in india online prednisone medicine treatment order vermox in canada does letrozole work better than clomid cheap canadian motilium no prescription what does prometrium 100 mg look like buy online quetiapinum generic prescription levitra online canada celadrin tablets online buy brand viagra online no prescription canada buy ampicillin in india online research grade mircette lithium buy canada where female cialis why has ginseng been discontinued neurontin online in uk metronidazol online glucotrol xl for sale erythromycin ethylsuccinate acne ginette 35 daily use reviews flucazole no prescription needed where to buy himcocid online usa nolvadex for gyno during cycle where to buy acai berry products in south africa purchase tretinoin in uk erection pills without side effects best disulfiramo prices fucidin order canada order prozac without rx what drug category is fucidin buy malegra dxt tablets australia costco pharmacy levitra super active price hyaluronic acid injections price london zovirax on line in the mexico vitamin shoppe return policy opened items western drug indocin buy cafergot us order lamisilate uk pharmacy buy dilantin from india prilosec dose for dogs cost of seroquel uk where to get aspirin in singapore purchase ampicilina mg order clomid 25 mg buy neurontin singapore buy diarex greece purchase orlistato on line in australia accutane fast mexico skelaxin without a prescription from us india pharmacies online that sell duetact over the counter one atarax online how to purchase oxybutyninum buy misoprost with paypal india pharmacies online that sell speman buy moduretic canada minocin india pharmacy comparison of cialis levitra or viagra inderal 100 mg lisinopril generic prinivil buy nizagara mg online for antabuse online with out prescription what does maxalt taste like buy femcare online ireland decadron cheap india pharmacy villaggio italiano yasmin resort wellbutrin india pharmacy half price coumadin mexico pharmacies online that sell norvasc zoloft ships from india power slim acai berry diet reviews cheap frumil amlodipine 10mg canadian norvasc diovan pills online in the uk can you get styplon generic meloxicam enolat switzerland buying seroflo in manchester levitra overnight without prescription oristal uk no prescription safe skelaxin no precription vpxl fast uk erexor brand pills for sale oral baclofen side effects in children diflucan order canada cheap atarax pills pharmacy rx world scam alesse mexico no prescription long time side effects diprolene order lantus without rx anastrozolo express canada buy eltroxin australia best place to buy methotrexate without a prescription what does robaxin have in it drugstore hyzaar online losartan is there over the counter treatment for chlamydia endep cheap us pharmacy cialis uk express delivery pfizer zyvox coupon medicine purchase brand viagra on line in india generic ventolin for sale on line generic substitute for vytorin how long does it take for voltaren to kick in retino a cream 0 025 discount cheap procardia sale uk generic lynoral no prescription cymbalta shop net metronidazole alcohol sick buy over the counter alphagan online natural alternative to doxycycline hyclate aygestin daily use reviews clomiphene citrate price in the philippines indocin pills shop azulfidine side effects long term use order ayurvedic medicines online buy aciclovir uk online pharmacy femara purchase moduretic without a prescription from india best place to buy amoxiline without a prescription order colchicine on line india buy tadalis sx online no prescription usa why is it important to take levothyroxine on an empty stomach alesse for discount ethinyl estradiol midamor low dose birth control zantac 150 recommended dosage isoptin uk sale how to use brahmi oil buy bupron sr pills in the uk levlen from europe albuterol inhaler generic hfa lipitor india price where can you buy qsymia buy augmentin cheap online generic aceon buy prednisolone no prescription arjuna ranatunga vs australia levitra no prescription online generic viagra canadian allied forces next evista next day delivery buy actonel online canada tenormin mg price best over the counter antibiotic eye drops online chemist australia viagra do you need rx azitromicina what is lamictal xr where to buy rosuvastatin with amex best site to buy diakof celebrex and cold medicine buy deltasone with a mastercard buy xenical online from india aristocort buy mexico discount canadian pharmacy carbozyne atarax anxiety medication zestril tablets 40mg promethazine with codeine syrup red buy calcium carbonate australia buy propecia ireland pharmacies generic atarax online generic clozaril no prescription order parlodel on line mexico retin a 0,025 on line no script where to buy fincar online india doxi 1 no prescription compare prices tesco pharmacy online shopping maxalt 10 mg tablets what is the best drugstore foundation for dry skin generic kamagra paypal betapace sotalol cost can buy prednisolone online order diclofenac us symptoms of withdrawal from effexor xr serevent cheap uk purchase pyridium on line in mexico what does prednisone pills look like anacin comprare what is propranolol 10 mg used for ashwagandha indian herb phenergan pills for nausea how to buy arimidex in london purchase relafen on line in the uk omeprazole and warfarin drug interactions digoxin without a script mestinon pharmacy prices list suhagra prescription only renagel drugstore.com asda asthma inhalers over the counter how to by keppra synthroid ordering no prescription canada and simvastatina microzide pills albuterol mexico pharmacy us based no prescription meds what is clavamox for cats used for undissolved metformin pills in stool zyprexa on the internet benadryl without rx zovirax pills and birth control purchase metoclopramide online doxycycline without prescrip